Is it reasonable for many places in Gansu to require low-risk return to Gansu for three days at their own expense?

Epidemic prevention policies are changing, so we can't simply look at the control measures at that time in various places with the current epidemic prevention policies.

Hometown people

Many places in Gansu asked for a low-risk return to Gansu for three days at their own expense. The earliest report can be traced back to Mr. Wang who returned to Lintao County, Dingxi City, Gansu Province from Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province on June 1. At that time, the epidemic area control standard: Dingxi City implemented a three-day centralized isolation at their own expense for all low-risk areas from other provinces, because the epidemic prevention and control were all territorial management, and each place was controlled by the city's policies.

then the local epidemic control measures are specific, targeted and real-time, and the goals are to control the epidemic, prevent external import and internal rebound, and avoid local epidemic emergencies endangering people's lives.

this is understandable, so it is best to report to the local community in advance for cross-provincial and cross-city flows, and know the local epidemic prevention control measures in advance to avoid some free and orderly flows that are taken for granted.

On the other hand, National Health Commission's "Nine Prohibitions" notice was issued on June 5th, which probably said: On the premise of unswervingly adhering to the general strategy of "importing from outside and preventing rebound from inside" and the general policy of "dynamically clearing", all localities should coordinate epidemic prevention and control and economic and social development more efficiently, further improve the scientific, accurate and targeted prevention and control measures, and resolutely prevent simplification, across-the-board and layer-by-layer overweight.

Therefore, it is wrong in itself to criticize a control measure of returning to Gansu on June 1 with an epidemic prevention notice dated June 5. The epidemic prevention policy can be described as changing day by day. Since it is impossible to predict the future, we should abide by the local control standards at that time for the sake of epidemic control and health and safety.

epidemic prevention and control

however, we can look at the matter of low-risk return to Gansu and self-funded isolation from another level.

First of all, due to the large financial expenditure on epidemic prevention and control in various places, it is inevitable to isolate at one's own expense, and the government cannot always cover the bottom, but the isolation expenses must be open and transparent, the composition details must be calculated reasonably, and humanistic care is also essential. According to relevant news reports, Mr. Wang's total isolation cost is more than 5 yuan (including all expenses such as transshipment, two-day accommodation, catering and nucleic acid). Compared with the self-funded isolation in the province and city where the author lives, the daily cost of centralized isolation in the two places is basically the same.

Secondly, whether the low-risk return should be isolated or not, which involves specific control measures in various places. Dingxi, Gansu Province has three days of centralized control+two times of nucleic acid detection, while the author's place is three days of home health monitoring+two times of nucleic acid detection. The breakdown standards of epidemic control in different places are different and can only vary from place to place.

Therefore, it was reasonable for many places in Gansu to require low-risk return to Gansu for three days at their own expense. It is unreasonable to put it here at this time. It is no small matter to prevent and control the epidemic. Accurate prevention and control warms people's hearts.

finally, the good news is that Lintao County, Dingxi, Gansu Province issued the latest notice on June 6, saying that green code personnel coming from low-risk areas outside the province need to provide negative proof of nucleic acid within 48 hours before they can flow in an orderly manner without centralized isolation.

layers of overweight are not allowed.