How many houses collapsed in Shouguang, Shandong?

According to a report on August 23rd, in recent days, floods in Shandong have worried people all over the country. More than 5 million people in the province were affected, 18 people died. Shouguang, the "hometown of vegetables" in the north, is particularly serious, and the victims are crying.

There is a disaster figure today, but it has aroused the interest of the media and Weibo V. Some media reported that "Shouguang flood caused 13 deaths, 3 people were missing, and houses in nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine collapsed", saying: "Weifang just held the first press conference on flood control and disaster relief: the disaster caused direct economic losses of 9.2 billion, * * * caused 13 deaths and 3 people were missing. In this disaster, houses in nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine collapsed and more than 200,000 greenhouses were damaged. "

Soon, someone "moved" the provisions in the National Emergency Plan for Natural Disaster Relief. For one of them, if the number of collapsed houses exceeds 10000, but is less than 100000, the level IV response will be started. After the disaster relief response is launched, the National Disaster Reduction Committee will co-ordinate the natural disaster relief work at the national level and guide and support the natural disaster relief work in the affected areas.

Houses collapsed in nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine. Isn't there just one room away from 1 10,000? The subtext of questioning is obvious. Local governments want to avoid launching national emergency response and fear being held accountable.

Attentive netizens noticed that at the press conference held by Weifang Municipal People's Government on August 23rd, the official made it clear that "Weifang has started the third, second and first-level response to natural disaster relief, and the provincial government started the third-level response. On the 22nd, 18 was upgraded to the provincial second-level emergency response, and the state started the fourth-level response."

According to the manuscript published by Shandong local media Qilu Evening News on 23rd, the official news of "nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine House Collapse" was released almost at the same time. The original text of Qilu Evening News is, as of 22nd 16: 00, between collapsed houses in nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine:

As of August 22nd 16, Weifang City1476,900 people were affected, 10 people were dead, 6 people were missing,170,800 people were resettled urgently, and 3 1700 people needed emergency living assistance. The affected area of crops is 654.38+042.5 thousand hectares, including 67.2 thousand hectares and 20.7 thousand hectares. Nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine houses collapsed, 7,320 houses were seriously damaged, and 35,959 houses were generally damaged; The direct economic loss was 9.253 billion yuan, including 4.558 billion yuan from agriculture.

Therefore, on the evening of 22nd, the Weifang Municipal Government released the disaster data, and at the same time, the state also launched a four-level response. Therefore, there is no time to "shelter from the wind" with false data.

Another, logically, the above speculation is also unreasonable. If we carefully read the National Emergency Plan for Natural Disaster Relief, we can find that Article 2 of the General Principles clearly stipulates that the conditions for starting the national emergency response are: meteorological disasters such as floods, droughts, typhoons, hail, snowstorms and sandstorms, geological disasters such as mountain collapses, landslides and mudslides, marine disasters such as storm surges and tsunamis, and natural disasters such as forest and grassland fires within a certain administrative region of a province (autonomous region or municipality). More than 654.38+10,000 people were resettled due to the disaster; More than 0/0000 houses collapsed due to the disaster.

In other words, if one of the three conditions is met, the national emergency response will be started. Let's read it again. How many victims have Weifang resettled-

Weifang suffered the worst disaster. According to the statistics on August 22nd 16, Weifang city1476,900 people were affected, 10 people were killed, 6 people were missing,170,800 people were urgently transferred and resettled, and 3 1700 people needed emergency living assistance. Affected area of crops 142500 hectares; Nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine houses collapsed; The direct economic loss was 9.253 billion yuan, including 4.558 billion yuan from agriculture.

1.7 million people. The data released by Weifang Municipal Government is in line with the national emergency response. The National Disaster Reduction Committee coordinated its work, and then fabricated a wrong data to make itself fired as such a "stupid bad guy". The possibility is really too low.

According to the data of Shandong Province, as early as August 20th, the National Emergency Management Department had released the news that "the National Disaster Reduction Committee and the Emergency Management Department urgently launched the national level IV emergency response of Typhoon Wambia in Shandong". The data in the Bulletin of Emergency Management Department are as follows:

According to the report of Shandong Provincial Department of Civil Affairs, due to the heavy rainfall brought by Typhoon Wambia, some areas in Shandong Province have suffered severe floods since August 19. By 7: 00 on August 20th, there were 3.807 million counties (cities, districts) in Weifang, Zibo, Tai 'an and other cities 13. 1.300 houses collapsed and 24,000 houses were damaged to varying degrees; The affected area of crops is 397 thousand hectares, of which 23.7 thousand hectares will not be harvested.

At this time, Shandong Province has transferred and resettled more than 65,438+10,000 people, which constitutes the condition for the national four-level emergency response. Moreover, "a working group composed of disaster relief department, fire bureau, national disaster reduction center and other units has been urgently dispatched to the disaster area to check the disaster situation on the spot and guide and support the local authorities to do a good job in emergency rescue and disaster relief and personnel search and rescue".

Therefore, whether in time or in logic, the possibility of "fabricating disaster data in nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine" is incomprehensible.

The truth is likely to disappoint Keyboard Man. How did the number nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine come from? The high probability is that the disaster relief personnel at all levels report and summarize the disaster situation, and the final result is exactly this figure. Of course, another possibility cannot be ruled out. Some people just want to scribble a number, regardless of interests.

The local government should also respond to online public opinion in a timely manner, eliminate unnecessary suspicion and panic, maintain credibility, and let the disaster relief work go smoothly.