Which is better, communicative German or new elegance?

1, Communicative German is a textbook of spoken German, which contains a lot of practical and vivid dialogues between spoken German and actual scenes. The dialogue scenes selected in this textbook are practical, such as booking a hotel, ordering food and asking for directions. , can help learners quickly master the expression skills needed when living and working in German-speaking countries.

2. The new refinement is a comprehensive German textbook, including listening, speaking, reading, writing and translation. It pays attention to the interpretation and application of German grammar. Texts are selected from excellent literary works, news reports and scientific and technological fields in German-speaking countries, and teaching materials pay more attention to writing.