What's Good reveals that Xiao Hong and Luo have no "sister-in-law".

During the release of the film Xiao Hong, some scholars pointed out that the pursuit of "gossip" in the film was inconsistent with historical facts. Teacher Zhang, the son of Luo, one of the leading characters in the film, pointed out in an interview that the love in the four corners of Xiao Hong made the outside world mistakenly think that Xiao Jun, Duanmu Hongliang and Luo had hatred because they loved the same woman, became enemies and even spread Xiao.

Xiao Jun, Duanmu Hongliang and Luo are all outstanding writers in Northeast China. In 1930s, they met because of Xiao Hong, and later became friends because of Xiao Hong.

Xiao Hong did die in Luo.

When Zhang was a child, he often listened to his father Luo telling stories. He was also very sensitive to personal mistakes in the movie Little Red. He said that Luo had two misunderstandings about the obvious defects in the film. "My father is a brave man and he is my friend. When taking care of lonely Xiaohong, he is a completely frank and friendly friend, which also includes the simple feelings that his younger brother loves his younger sister. Second, it seems that my father left Xiao Hong at the last minute of the movie, which is also wrong. In fact, when the Japanese began bombing Hong Kong, left-wing writers were ready to retreat to the mainland, and my father Luo was also ready to retreat with Mao Dun and others. But considering his old friend Xiaohong's younger brother, tell his sister that she is very ill in Hong Kong and is in hospital, and ask him to see him at his convenience. Thinking that Xiaohong needed transportation, her father went to the hospital to find her and helped Duanmu Hongliang settle Xiaohong in the hotel. Just as my father was preparing to say goodbye to Xiao Hong, Duanmu Hongliang disappeared. Tell Xiaohong that he won't come back, and let him stay and take care of her and spend the last 44 days with her. At first, my father didn't bring any change of clothes. He still remembers the manuscript of Man and Land, which he studied hard at home for two years. So he saw Xiaohong's condition improved and Duanmu appeared, so he told Xiaohong that he was going home to get something. I don't know that I couldn't go back that day because of the sudden martial law in Japan. When he came to Xiaohong again the next day, she was unconscious and died in her father's arms. "

Luo Xiaojun is not a rival in love but a friend.

Zhang said that the "love in four corners" in the movie Xiao Hong made the outside world mistakenly think that Xiao Jun, Duanmu Hongliang and Luo hated each other and turned against each other because they loved the same woman. There is even a saying on the Internet: "Xiao Hong promised to marry Luo if she gets better after leaving Duanmu Hongliang.

Zhang told reporters: "My father and Duanmu Hongliang openly turned against each other, not for the intimacy of Xiao Hong, but because my father thought that Duanmu Hongliang had no responsibility as a man and abandoned Xiao Hong at the most critical moment. My father described these contradictions in detail in the preface to the revised edition of Xiao Hong Zhuan. For more than 50 years, Duanmu Hongliang and Xiao Jun have not had any public debate on this matter. In fact, my father and Jun have been friends since then, and the descendants of our two families have continued this friendship. "

collect

Not the uncle of Luo writer Jason.

Zhang did not follow in his father's footsteps in writing. Now he is the president of China International Ice Wine Federation. He said that young people are very unfamiliar with the history of Xiao Hong's era, and the film Xiao Hong may be one of the few ways for them to understand that distant era. "I am very grateful to the film Little Red, which taught young people an important lesson in the history of modern literature in China." But at the same time, I don't want my father's image to be surrounded by many false information. What is particularly unacceptable is that his personality has been wrongly portrayed. Although the film is dramatic and needs to cater to secular interests, the so-called artistic treatment should be as close to history and people as possible because of its real name. "

He also clarified by the way: "Baidu search Luo Xiang explained that my father is the uncle of writer Jason, which is also wrong." My father and Jason's father are actually very good friends. He always points out Jason's works before he became famous.

truth

Sick Xiaohong

Luo, formerly known as Zhang, was admitted to Peking University on 1934, and likes literary creation. Soon, he heard that Xiao Jun's Country in August and Xiao Hong's Field of Life and Death were published with the support of Lu Xun. So he decided to follow in the footsteps of Xiao Jun and Xiao Hong to find Lu Xun. When he sent the first two chapters of the novel The Border to Lu Xun, Lu Xun was too ill to direct his writing. After the "August 13th" war broke out, he went to eastern Zhejiang to participate in the anti-Japanese and national salvation work under the recommendation of Mao Dun.

194 1 After the Southern Anhui Incident, he went into exile in Hong Kong and began to write the novel Man and Land. At that time, he didn't have much money on him, and he didn't have any money to open a shop for a few days. I had to seek the help of Duanmu Hongliang, an exiled writer in Northeast China. Duanmu Hongliang's client paid for Luo's shop and arranged a place for him. At the same time, he also published Luo's novel Man and Land in Time Literature, which contributed to Luo's livelihood.

Soon, the Pacific War broke out and Luo planned to leave Hong Kong. When Luo called Duanmu and Xiaohong to say goodbye, Duanmu asked him if he could stay in Hong Kong to help take care of Xiaohong, who was seriously ill. Luo generously agreed and immediately rushed to their residence. Due to the emergency in Hong Kong, Duanmu Hongliang and Luo Daihong took refuge at home, Enhao Hotel and Times Bookstore dormitory respectively. On February 25th, 65438, Hong Kong fell and many progressives left Hong Kong. At this time, Xiaohong had swollen throat, chest tightness and difficulty breathing, and was taken to Yanghe Hospital. Because of the doctor's misdiagnosis, Xiaohong was greatly weakened during the operation and became weaker. Later, Xiaohong was sent to a temporary hospital converted from St. Stephen's Girls' School. 1942 65438+1On October 22nd, Xiao Hong died in this hospital.

During the 44 days from the outbreak of the Pacific War to Xiao Hong's death, according to the preface of the revised version of Xiao Hong Biography, Luo always guarded Xiao Hong's side. Xiao Hong was very ill and said to Luo, "Duanmu Zheng will fight them to the death. Starting today, I won't come. He has said goodbye to me. " Therefore, Duanmu Hongliang is always accused of putting the responsibility of nursing on Xiao Hong at the critical moment of her life. However, Duanmu Hongliang's wife Zhong Yaoqun wrote the book Duanmu Hongliang and Xiao Hong, but later claimed that Duanmu Hongliang left Xiao Hong to buy food and medicine and find a hospital that was not taken over by the Japanese army. After Xiao Hong's death, Duanmu Hongliang had her body photographed and put a lock of Xiao Hong's hair in her arms. I also bought an ordinary porcelain bottle with Xiaohong's ashes in it at a high price. The next day, he and Luo buried Xiaohong's urn in Repulse Bay.

What is the truth of the matter? Considering that both Duanmu Hongliang and Luo are dead, it is hard to say who is right or wrong. However, from the end of February 1942, Duanmu Hongliang, Luo and others left Hong Kong and moved from "Silver Bay" to Guilin. It is a mystery that Duanmu Hongliang didn't leave Hong Kong during Xiao Hong's critical illness and how many days he didn't accompany Xiao Hong.

Stills of the movie "Golden Age"

develop

I love Duanmuliang best.

1938 1 At the invitation of Li Gongpu, Xiao Hong, Xiao Jun and Duanmu Hongliang came to Linfen, Shanxi Province to teach at the National Revolutionary University. During her stay in Linfen, Xiao Hong had more contact with Duanmu Hongliang and had a feeling of "hate before marriage" towards Duanmu Hongliang. In particular, Duanmu Hongliang once said in public that Xiao Jun literature was inferior to Xiao Hong, which satisfied Xiao Hong's vanity. Soon, Linyi City was in chaos, and Xiao Jun prepared to retreat with the National Revolutionary University. Xiao Hong and Duanmu Hongliang joined the Northwest Field Service Corps and returned to Xi. This means that the relationship between Xiao Hong and Xiao Jun, who have lived for six years, has broken down. Half a month later, when Xiao Jun and Xiao Hong met in Xi, Xiao Hong had made a promise with Duanmu Hongliang, so they had to choose to break up. Xiao Hong and Duanmu Hongliang immediately went to Wuhan. In May of the same year, Xiao Hong and Duanmu Hongliang got married in Wuhan Datong Hotel. At the wedding, Hu Feng suggested that they fall in love. Xiao Hong said: "Duanmu Hongliang and I have no romantic love history." When I decided to leave Saburo forever, I found Duanmu Hongliang. "

1August, 938, Japan bombed Wuhan, and the people fled. They decided to evacuate to Chongqing. Luo Feng gave birth to a dead baby in his hometown in Chongqing.

At the end of 1939, Japanese planes conducted reconnaissance and bombing in Beibei almost every day. Xiaohong's lung disease is getting worse and worse. He consulted Hiroichi Duanmu, hoping to take refuge in Hong Kong. 1940 65438+ 10, Xiao Hong and Duanmu Hongliang came to Hong Kong from Chongqing and lived at No.8 Yuedao, Tsim Sha Tsui, Kowloon. Xiao Hong finished the novel Biography of Hulan River here, and Duanmu Hongliang created the pre-Qin history. Xiaohong is very weak at this time, feeling depressed and worried mentally. 194165438+On February 8, the Pacific War broke out and Japan occupied Kowloon, Hong Kong. At that time, Xiaohong's lung disease became more and more serious. Duanmu Hongliang entrusted Luo, a literary friend, to take care of Xiao Hong. 1942 65438+1On the morning of October 22nd, Xiao Hong passed away at the age of 3 1.