Looking for loopholes in Jin Yong's martial arts novels.

First, "flying snow shoots at Bailuyuan, laughing at Xia Yiyuan, the god of books."

Hundreds of versions of Jin Yong's novels have been published, and there are countless pirated versions. The editors and proofreaders of each edition are different, and there are countless typos, language errors and inconsistencies in some editions. Such a bug is beyond the scope of discussion. The focus is on history, logic, inheritance and other plot "bugs" that cannot be justified, and the controversial loopholes about the complex side of human nature are different.

Second, common sense and knowledge.

1, I won't talk about poetry crossing, I need to describe it.

2. Duan Yu drinks "Biluochun" in Yanziwu, Suzhou.

3. Guo Jing drinks Longjing in Changqing Building.

Biluochun and Longjing are brand names, not category names, but China's own. However, the great crossing age of Biluochun and Longjing, which appeared six or seven hundred years later, is too unreasonable for Mr. Jin Yong, who inherited Jiangnan.

4. Ah Zi eats with silver ("Tianlong Babu")

In the Northern Song Dynasty, it was copper coins and jiaozi, and the passage of silver was in the Ming Dynasty.

Wu was beheaded by the exterminator when six factions besieged Guangmingding, and was later intact.

6, "Book Sword" Wu Liujiang sang "Peach Blossom Fan", "Peach Blossom Fan" has gone through 34 years.

7. After the arm fracture, Yang Guo showed menstruation the breaststroke skills with his hands on the ground.

8. The smelting skill in Song Dynasty has reached a level that I, a modern person, can't understand:

The dragon sword in "Eternal Dragon Slayer" is hard to melt. It took several days to forge this sword with extraordinary internal force and blazing flame, but there is still a sandwich inside. Jiuyin Zhen Jing and Wu Mu's suicide note have been well preserved? Is it magnetic levitation technology? No, the hollow layer of the sword is sealed, and the thermal conductivity of the air forged for a long time will also turn the book into fly ash. If it is cast sealed, there should be an opening mechanism. Why do swords cut each other? If the hollow degree of the sword is too large, there will be noise, but outsiders don't know that the hollow layer of the sword is close to the scriptures and suicide notes so that the secret will not be discovered. Then the problem comes again. Even if there was seamless metal sealing technology in ancient times, it should be heated and melted again at the sealing place, and heat conduction came again. .....

9. Duan Yu and Wang Yuyan were chased by Xixia soldiers, and Duan Yu's six-pulse Excalibur bounced off the beam, killing a soldier. Why not explain the magical six-pulse Excalibur? What can bounce off a wooden beam and kill the powerful Xixia people?

Third, history.

1, "The Condor Heroes" Yang Guo shoots Meng Ge in Xiangyang. Pity me, Brother Khan, who was killed twice in Fishing City and Xiangyang City.

2. The Russian envoy in the Duke of Lushan calls himself "Marquis Romono Sava", and this "Romono Sava" is "lomonosov", named after 1948 in St. Petersburg. This city did not exist in the Kangxi era, and its place did not belong to Russia.

3. The theme that Mr. Jin put the sculpture in the Southern Song Dynasty comes from The Romance of Yue Fei. Genghis Khan attacked the Song Dynasty in his book. The fact is that Genghis Khan made an alliance with the Song Dynasty eight years after his death to destroy the gold. Destroy the gold, Mongolia cut the song. This brings a series of puzzles, so I'll just say a few main ones.

(1) In the shooting, Han Shizhong will get the "Wu Mu's suicide note". In fact, about 20 years after Yue Fei's death, when the Southern Song Dynasty went north, why didn't the Korean Ministry hand it over to Zhang Jun (the leader of Yue Fei's old headquarters), Yu, Yang Cunzhong and Liu Qi (comrade Yue Fei was there), but insisted on hiding it (Guo Jing, the commander, took it away)?

(2) Wu Mu's suicide note appears in the sky continuously. Here comes the problem. As a famous contemporary of Yue Fei, Han Shizhong (died in 1 15 1), Yue Fei was born in 1 178 in Wumu, posthumous title. Han Shizhong reincarnated and named the suicide note "Wu Mu's suicide note"?

(3) When Wan Yan Honglie was young, he used Jiaxing magistrate as a dog. I personally went to Lin' an to scold the Prime Minister of the Southern Song Dynasty (the Prime Minister was frightened); I fell in love with Bao Xiruo again in Lin 'an, and then mobilized (became the Jin Puppet Army) to destroy the Bao family ... The fact is, 1206, Temujin Khan, Guo Jing returned to the Central Plains that year. Mr. Jin has repeatedly said that the imperial court is in dire straits. In fact, 1206 was cutting gold in the Southern Song Dynasty. Three years ago, the atmosphere of the main battle was unusually high, so I borrowed ten leopards from Hong Yanlie. ......

Duan Yu was born in Baoding, Dali for two years (1023). In the 27th episode of Eight Branches of the Dragon, Xiao Feng and Ah Zi met Yelu Hongji, the emperor of Liao, who was out hunting on the road, which happened to be a civil strife in Liao (this year was 1063). Duan Yu was 40 years old at this time. In the seventh year of Song Zhezong Yuan You (1092, Xiao Feng 3 1 year), Xiao Feng and Lu Ye Hongji became sworn. According to the development of the plot, Duan Yu, who is "youthful", was 70 years old when he became sworn to Xiao and (1093), and he was a young "third brother".

5. At the end of "Dragon", the Empress Dowager Song died, and Zhezong personally led the Southern Expedition of Liao. Xiao Fenggang helped Lu Ye Hongji to counter the rebellion. These two events are 30 years apart.

6. Li Tianlong, the king of South Campus, became a title.

In fact, it is an official position: "Taizu is divided into two kings, the North and the South, which are called the North and South Courtyards. The Prime Minister, Tommy, Xuanzang and Lin Ya, down to the husband and bodyguard, are divided into the north and the south. In fact, they are all ruled by the north ... "-"Liao History Volume 45 Baiguan Record 15 "

..... there are still a few, can't be exhausted.

If you don't pay attention to history, why not put it on the shelf and give it the background of the times? Of course, it is understandable for creative needs, but the problems exposed are essentially problems of skills and homework. Although the value and contribution of literature have not been greatly affected, people who understand history are extremely uncomfortable to read (there are not a few such readers). Of course, historical mistakes affect the whole body, and novels are really difficult to change (changing is rewriting, a huge project), so it depends on "romance genre"

7. Historical mistakes are still regarded as "romance", and so is the novel itself: Wang Zhongyang died before Guo Jing was born and Lin Chaoying died before Wang Zhongyang 10 years ago. In other words, Wang Zhongyang died more than 50 years earlier than Duan Wang and Ouyang Feng, and Lin Chaoying died more than 60 years earlier. The little dragon girl who abandoned the baby was adopted by her mother-in-law Is there any evidence that this mother-in-law is a disciple of Lin Chaoying? So, the little dragon girl is only four years older than Yang Guo?

Fourth, the plot:

1, Old Deno defected before, and Zuo Lengchan knew that the swordsmanship to ward off evil spirits was fake?

2. Xiao Yuanshan cornered his son step by step, which is totally inconsistent with his wisdom of enduring in Shaolin Temple for 20 years-Xiao Feng saved Ah Zi at the Wulin Congress, and Xiao Feng himself said that he would never set foot in the Central Plains again. And Xiao Yuanshan always kills first. Can he force Xiao Feng to return to Daliao? Xiao Feng's life experience is unknown. Shouldn't Feng Xiaoxian know his life experience? Kill Qiao Sanhuai and Xuan Ku so that Xiao Feng doesn't know who he is. How can he tell the truth? Other elders killed were Shan Zheng, Xu, Zhao Gan Sun, etc. , Xiao Feng is to investigate who is the lead brother, should not be Xiao Feng to investigate clearly, and then to settle accounts with Xuan Ci?

Zuo Lengchan, a proud man, finally lost to Yue Buqun. One of the main reasons is that he used fake swords to ward off evil spirits. Moreover, this fake swordsmanship is specious with the real swordsmanship, and it is obviously a fabricated work by someone who knows the real swordsmanship (otherwise, you can't trust a master like Zuo Lengchan). According to the original records, this fake sword was forged by Yue Buqun and brought to Zuo Lengchan by Lao Denuo on purpose. In other words, Yue Buqun made up this fake sword score only after he got the real sword score and understood it. However, the timeline is like this: Ling Huchong fainted after picking up the sword score in Fuzhou-the sword score disappeared after waking up-Ling Huchong fought with Paizhong Town in Songshan-Yue Buqun refused the help of Hengshan Sect-Hengshan sent his men to fight with Lao Denuo-Laudno Xia Zi fled after the secret was exposed. Less than a day, how did Yue Buqun compile a fake music score in such a short time and let Lao Denuo take it away in a reasonable way? Prophet? That's great.

4. People in Jin Yong's novels are difficult to talk, misunderstand and make trouble.

This is what Wang Shuo said, and there are different opinions. It is true that many plots begin and then are misunderstood. Don't do it if you do it. To tell the truth, to tell the truth ... although this is the creative skill of plot conception, it is not too much. Xiao Feng and his son, Murong and his son, and the abbot, Daobaifeng and Duan, Duan and Duan Yu and a group of "sisters", and Aru, Wang Yuyan and Murong Bo, as well as tragic cruising ... There are countless misunderstandings, and this is just a dragon.

Sixth, the title

I have read the vernacular works of a strong man with a net name. The enemy said to the protagonist, "Do you have anyone else?" There is also an online work in which the protagonist claims to be "the next XXX ……", which is very humorous in the face of the father-killer. Look at Tianlong, Xixia is a big summer, and all the books call themselves "My Xixia", which is similar to calling themselves "I am a barbarian".

About crops (corn, apples, etc. ) eaten by Jin Yong's novels.

Does the miracle of the world only exist between you and me? Do not be blind.

The characters in many novels, such as the condor, the handheld device maker, the dragon, etc. They all ate all kinds of crops from America n years in advance.

American Indians originated in ancient China (there is no objection in archaeology). Do they have to travel without seeds?

"April is beautiful, May is full of flowers" (The Book of Songs, July). Four thousand years ago, China had tuber food. Yam and potato are mixed together. Must there be no potatoes (or early potato varieties)?

"When millet leaves, it is the seedling of millet" (The Book of Songs). This is not a corn seedling, nor a sorghum seedling. Please name one. The famous "six valleys" in the Zhou Dynasty-rice, sorghum, rice, millet and millet-are pronounced Shu. In the northeast, sorghum rice is called glutinous rice, and sorghum straw is called glutinous rice, that is, millet straw.

During the Southern and Northern Dynasties, the Book of Qi Yao Min recorded a variety of crops, many of which were similar to Borapin, but there was no evidence that many crops were introduced to China during the Qin and Han Dynasties.

Rice seeds were discovered before 8900, and tomato and sorghum seeds were unearthed in batches in ancient tombs of the Western Han Dynasty (tomato seeds can sprout into branches).

According to Cihai, apples are native to tropical areas, and the southern part of China had a tropical climate in ancient times. Don't forget, Shang and Zhou Dynasties (Saudi Arabia and Ling Lin) still have bonuses? These fruits taste like apples. South Korea has called apples "Shaguo" for nearly a thousand years, and it was called "Lin Ling" during the Edo period in Japan!

In Jin Yong's novels set in the Song Dynasty, only peanuts and peppers are generally inedible.

Of course, martial arts novels are not academic novels. Why bother eating something wrong once in a while? So, I don't think this is a loophole.

Eight. Controversy over a major loophole

Mu Rongfu didn't know Chinese characters, but Duan Yu saw the words "Deal with a man as he deals with you" on the wall, so he asked if Ah Zhu was written by Mu Rongfu. Ah Zhu said, "My son is good at writing all kinds of fonts, but I can't see them. "

Please note, when did Mr. Jin Yong say that Mu Rongfu could not read?

The words "Guo Yan, Guo Yan" entered Duan Yu's ears ... Murong's, Yanziwu, Shenhezhuang and Guo Yan ... Duan Yu blurted out: "This Murong son is a descendant of Murong, a Xianbei man in the Five Chaos Years of China? He is a semi-final of the conference, not China? " Wang Yuyan: "Yes, he is the grandson of Murong in Yan State. But it's been hundreds of years, so why should we recall our ancestors' past? He wants to be a semi-final of the conference, not a China. He doesn't even want to know Chinese characters or read China's books. Well, I don't see anything wrong with China's book. Once I said,' Cousin, you said China's books were not good, but I'd like to see if there are any books in Xianbei.' He was very angry because there were no books in Xianbei. "

Just because you don't want to learn doesn't mean you won't learn. How many young people really like reading now? The original text can only prove that Mu Rongfu hates China culture, but can't prove that he is illiterate. As a student group in China, we hate to learn a lot of foreign languages, but we didn't pass T and I as usual. As a national subjugator who devotes himself to saving the country, will he be so willful as not to learn the mainstream culture of the ruling class? And because he wants to study, he wants to study deeply and master, but his heart is extremely hostile to the Han nationality, which is in line with the psychological distortion of Mu Rongfu shaped by Tianlong.

Master works, martial arts classics, nonsense comments, fear.