Which is better, the Old Frog 15 wide-angle macro lens or the Tuli 1 1- 16 lens?

APS frame lens; Equivalent focal length16-24 mm; The nearest focal length is 0.3m；; The maximum magnification is 0.086 times; Bayonets: Nikon, Canon; Auto focus.

Old Frog 15mm F4 Axis-shifting Wide-angle Macro Lens

Quan Huafu lens; The nearest focal length is 4.7mm；; The maximum photographic magnification is 1.0 times; Bayonets: Canon, Nikon, Pentax, Sony A, Sony E; Manual focus.

There are two kinds of lenses with different uses, one is a wide-angle zoom lens that can focus automatically, and the other is a macro lens with a fixed angle. In terms of imaging quality, all aspects of fixed focus correction will be more in place. In the way, they are all wide-angle positioning. There is little difference between wide-angle manual and autofocus. If you are used to wide-angle manual focusing, it will be more convenient and faster. Wide-angle macro will make your work more tension and impact. Nowadays, digital cameras will be equipped with real-time viewing, zooming and focusing functions, which is more convenient.

Personally, I think it's still the old frog 15 wide-angle macro lens. The wide-angle macro lens is unique, and the work will be more personalized, which will give you creative space.