Compared with the 87th edition of A Dream of Red Mansions, why is the new edition of A Dream of Red Mansions criticized?

The new TV series A Dream of Red Mansions should be said that great efforts have been made from the production director to the cast. From the perspective of photography and lighting effects, I personally think that the overall design is very soft and the illusion design is also very charming. Most people think that the image of the character and the performance of the actor are his failures. Part of the reason is the aesthetic tendency of producers and directors, which seems to be based on the image of a dream of red mansions painted in Qing Dynasty.

As far as A Dream of Red Mansions is concerned, before the broadcast of the old TV series, there was a movie series of A Dream of Red Mansions, in which most of the actors were famous stars, such as Feng Jie and Grandma Liu played by Zhao.

However, the old TV series A Dream of Red Mansions is still recognized by the audience. Most of the previous dramas and movies based on A Dream of Red Mansions have been adapted and performed, and most of them think that these previous works are obviously clumsy compared with the old TV series A Dream of Red Mansions. Therefore, the so-called "preconceived" psychological state alone cannot explain the audience's tendency in aesthetic taste.

Prejudice is a very profound psychological phenomenon. Other things being equal, people or animals measure the value of a thing with the mentality of "being the queen's minister first". Aesthetically, most of them are. The remakes of The Journey to the West's four classical novels, The Three Kingdoms, The Water Margin and A Dream of Red Mansions, are mostly original.

As far as things are concerned, the original intention of the new version of the Red Chamber is to respect the original work, but as far as the choice of actors is concerned, after all, gossip will not be said. The key is to completely break away from the original description. Baochai and Daiyu are completely opposite in appearance design, and you can't see where there is Chai Dai's temperament; Let's talk about Wang Xifeng. Although she is about the same age, she is not clever at all. ...

Actors' shapes and costumes are the same. They don't look like everyone's manners, but like standard art photos. A woman's hair feels awkward at first sight and disgusting at second sight.

Then there's music. It's weird. You said it was a ghost film and a classic remake. You said you were creating an atmosphere, but the point is that you didn't read the original.

A netizen said this:

Really holding the mentality of trying, I barely watched a few episodes by myself. I couldn't stand it anymore, so I gave up the play. When I brush Weibo, I see Tucao, but they are all real original fans! On the other hand, I watch the 87th edition of The Red Chamber. I have been a mother since I was a child. As soon as I talk about A Dream of Red Mansions, everyone will immediately talk about the actors in this TV series, which have already been deeply rooted in people's hearts and become a symbol of the times.

The shortcomings of the new version are also obvious. For example, the acting skills of actors are worrying. Now I only look at the young Baoyu stage, and my eyes are very clean, which is better than the old version. However, he can't compare with the old edition because he has nothing but cleanliness. Baoyu's respect and love for women is very good in the old version, but the young actors in the new version are not reflected at all.

I won't mention Daiyu. The new version was crushed by the old version this minute, and I am too lazy to evaluate the new version. The new version of Baochai is not bad. Qin Li's acting skills are in place, and he must have a passing grade.

If the old version of Xifeng's performance can get 90 points, then the new version can barely get 40 points, not more than one point. The new assassin has appeared several times, with no features at all, and looks ugly. The old version of The Assassin brought the Assassin back to life.

The new version of Qin Keqing is better than the old one, but the makeup feels like a leprechaun, which makes it easy to play. Other roles are not judged, and there are not so many appearances. Another trap is that the background music of the whole play is fascinating and mysterious, and the tone is really puzzling.

Therefore, the classic can become a classic because the public has recognized it. After years of precipitation, people still talk about it. This is the classic!