Which movie can bring tears to your eyes more, "Little Q" or "Hachi"?

Of course it is "Little Q".

"Guide Dog Little Q" is adapted by Cui Yangyi based on the writer Kengo Ishiguro's "Goodbye Kelu". This book truly records the life of a guide dog named Kelu. In addition to the simple text description, there are also important records of Kelu by photographer Akimoto Ryohei. The film is very faithful to the original work and pays attention to details. Every shot and scene is exactly the same as that shot by Akimoto Ryohei. Therefore, the film will inevitably give people the feeling of filming a documentary, and it does not deliberately create some particularly hypocritical and tear-jerking scenes for the sake of dramatic conflicts, but what I just like is this plain and restrained way of expressing emotions. Let people explode in silence. "Little Q" basically has nothing to do with the original work except that the protagonist is still Little Q. Compared with the blandness and restraint of the original work, this film not only amplifies the character traits of the blind character, but also the loyalty of Little Q, and the emotions of the foster family. The result is naturally more sensational and tear-jerking.

There are three scenes that are most unacceptable to me when watching dog movies. The first is to wait alone, forever. For example, there are several scenes of waiting for the owner in "Little Q". When he first arrived at Simon Yam's house, Little Q was forcibly dragged outside. On a rainy day, Little Q hid under the car and looked at the owner's window from a distance. The second one is to follow the car without caring about one's own safety, following the owner's departure. Scenes like this can easily make people cry. Previously, the director of "Hachiko" made "A Dog's Purpose" based on the novel of the same name. There was a scene in which Bailey chased Ethan driving a car in a wheat field. Watch The crazy chase to Bailey made me cry. The third is the farewell of death. In the original work, Watanabe died of kidney disease, and Little Q slowly aged. In "Little Q", Little Q gets sick and grows old. Whether it is the death of the owner or the dog, it is unacceptable.