My brother's classic is called Shun Liu and Liang Jian.

The same military masterpiece, the same protagonist. My brother's name is Shun Liu, which was broadcasted by CCTV and local TV stations in turn, and the ratings even surpassed Liang Jian. With the broadcast of Shun Liu, it has been controversial. Supporters think that Shun Liu's lines are humorous and beautiful, surpassing Liang Jian. Opponents said that Shun Liu had too many loopholes, was unreasonable, was far worse than Liang Jian, and failed.

Today, we might as well let Liu Shun and Liang Jian have an all-round PK directly to see who is better. Let's go ...

The first round: the plot

I don't know whether Shun Liu's screenwriter borrowed from Liang Jian's plot. I always feel that many plots of Shun Liu have Liang Jian's shadow. Generally speaking, Shun Liu's plot is more exaggerated, dramatic and relaxing. The plot in "Bright Sword" is even more tense, atmospheric and exciting. Both have their own advantages. However, the tragic ending of Shun Liu is too different and abrupt from the relaxed style before. I have to say it's a big failure.

This round PK: "Bright Sword" wins.

The second round: charm

Some people say that the characters in "Shun Liu" are very much like those in "Bright Sword" and have great personality. But if you watch these two plays carefully, you will find that the characters in them are far from each other. Now, Chu, and monk Wei are all indomitable heroes. In Shun Liu, Chen Dalei is not bold enough, not brave enough, far worse than Li Yunlong; Li Huan is not as aboveboard as Chu Yunfei and looks more like a hypocrite. As for being smooth, self-centered and cold-blooded (watching my sister be spoiled by the devil), I always feel a little awkward and disgusting.

This round of PK: "Bright Sword" wins

The third round: pictures

I have to say, "Bright Sword" is a rare good film in recent years. However, due to the shooting cost at that time and other reasons, there were many shortcomings in the picture performance, although it did not lose the atmosphere. Hua Qing, the director of Shun Liu, is a professional photographer, who has been focusing on film shooting before, and is unique in color application and detail description.

This round PK: "Shun Liu" won.

The fourth round: connotation

To be honest, I'm not sure what director Shun Liu really wants to convey to us. Perhaps I want to express my point of view, to be harmonious (after Japan surrendered, Sakata did not pursue it) and the overall situation (to kill the Japanese general and watch my sister suffer, indifferent). But when people look uncomfortable, they always feel angry. As for the "sword spirit", isn't it the exchange of this society?

This round of PK: "Bright Sword" wins

Comprehensive evaluation: "Bright Sword" is a complete victory.

From the above comparison, we can easily see that my brother's name is Shun Liu, which is not bad, but far from Liang Jian. If you are a man, you should be as brave as Li Yunlong, not as timid as smooth. By the way, I found a game called Liang Jian OL these two days, and it feels good. If you are interested, you can experience it.