Why did the senior director give a bad review when the cliff was broadcast on the Internet?

The Cliff directed by Zhang Yimou can be said to be one of the phenomenal movies of 202 1. The extended key continues to be shown in the cinema. At present, the box office has exceeded165438+700 million, which is behind the Spring Festival. Hello, Li Huanying, detective chinatown 3 and Fast and Furious 9, Godzilla vs King Kong, ranked fifth in the box office list of movies released on 202 1, that is, spies. It is also the highest-grossing film directed by Zhang Yimou, which has surpassed the more expensive Great Wall and can be said to be the most profitable work in Zhang Yimou. In addition, Xie Fei also won the Golden Rooster Award of China Film and the Shanghai Film Critics Association Award.

China Film Directors Association and other mainstream awards, his achievements in film art are beyond doubt, and his appreciation and criticism of movies are also quite authoritative. Similarly, in the film industry, as an influential and authoritative director, it is impossible for Xie Fei not to know about Zhang Yimou. He gave "Above the Cliff" two stars and criticized the weakness and control failure of the play. To say that he is not merciful at all must be his true opinion. Why is Xie Fei so severely criticized? In fact, the film directed by Xie Fei.

First of all, the first half criticizes the film's weakness and control failure. Xie Fei's first sentence is very interesting. He wrote that it can only be seen online. This means that although "The Cliff" has been shown in the cinema for nearly two months, he didn't spend money to see it. Instead, please wait until it is online. I don't know if he made such a decision because he didn't like Zhang Yimou's films and didn't handle and control such a weak drama well. It is not difficult to understand that four well-trained agents formed a task force on the cliff.

Being betrayed by a traitor, he was trapped by the enemy from the moment he parachuted to the ground. Only in our previous interview with photographer Zhao Xiaoding, he responded that the part where Liu Haocun jumped out of the car was originally shot for a complete scene. When Liu Haocun was discovered by the enemy, the regiment had already gone away, and the enemy who fought with her fell behind because of peeing, which is why the gunfire did not attract pursuers. Later, I found that the lock had been removed and escaped. Limited by the length of time, and because Zhang Yimou wanted to keep the atmosphere tense and fast-paced, these two parts were deleted a lot, and Xie Fei's last sentence offset the efforts of actors and audio-visual producers.

This shows that he recognized the actors' performances and the production of films, and the performances of Yu Hewei and Zhang Yi in the films were impressive. In addition, Zhang Yimou, who is over 70 years old, is still trying new fields of spy war and seeking breakthroughs in the film industry, such as shooting a large night scene in a film, setting the weather in extremely cold environment and snowing. Both of them have very good performances. No wonder director Xie Fei doesn't like drama, but he recognizes acting and production. Finally, I want to say that movies always have regrets and shortcomings. The box office and Douban score of Above the Cliff prove that the film has been widely recognized by the audience. Therefore, the shortcomings of the film can be seen, and the advantages of the film have been recognized. Xie Fei, is it too harsh to give two stars?