/kloc-is there really no place to win compared with the 87 version of the Red Mansion?

10 version of a dream of red mansions is a remake of version 87. From the perspective of film and television production, remake is not a bad thing, and different times have different views. On the one hand, the remake deepens the understanding of the novel, on the other hand, it helps to inherit the culture, which is a good thing. However, the remake of A Dream of Red Mansions was widely criticized, which embarrassed the producers. After reading 10 and version 87, the author briefly summarized five reasons why 10 version of A Dream of Red Mansions was not accepted by netizens:

First, the color of the picture is not properly matched. The main color of the picture does not match the colors of clothes, portraits, pavilions, clothes and utensils in the room. The old version of A Dream of Red Mansions takes white as the background color and red as the main color. These two colors create a festive and clear picture, while the 10 version of A Dream of Red Mansions takes gray as the background color and dark red as the main tone. These two colors are in harmony.

Second, the actor's understanding of the deductive role is not enough, there are too many performance elements and the depth of interpretation is too shallow. This feeling needs to be compared with 10 version or 87 version, otherwise you can't understand it. In the 87th edition of A Dream of Red Mansions, the actor's role is alive, and everyone's image in the play is vivid, but the 10 version gives people the impression that it is a performance, which is getting more and more fake and can't catch the audience's eye. For example, jie feng, the most distinctive figure in the novel, version 10, is blunt, although its words are pungent.

Third, costume design and character makeup are not bright enough. We watch the 87th edition of A Dream of Red Mansions. The clothes worn by Baochai, Daiyu and Maid are mostly red or pink, while those worn by grandmothers or daughters-in-law are mostly blue with red piping or red rhubarb. For example, the color of Xifeng is usually red, yellow and blue, and the clothes of the old slave are grayish brown. However, in the 10 version of A Dream of Red Mansions,

Fourthly, the background music and dubbing effect are not coherent enough. Literary and artistic works pay attention to distinct themes, and background music and special effects music serve to express the theme. However, in the 10 version of A Dream of Red Mansions, although the theme of sadness still exists, the festivals and special effects music of several songs are relatively independent, which leads to scattered themes. On the other hand, some themes are not consistent with those expressed in the 10 version of A Dream of Red Mansions, resulting in the whole.

Fifth, the characterization in the play is unsuccessful. In fact, this item is closely combined with the second and third items. We often talk about first impressions and second impressions. What is the first impression is related to people's clothes, and the second impression is the expression of this person's speech. If the first two expressions are successful, characterization is half the battle. Unfortunately, the first impression and the second impression of this drama are all failures, and the third impression consumes little spirit, so the characterization of the 10 version is not clear.

10 version of A Dream of Red Mansions has many problems. Maybe you can compare some stills of 10 and 87 to make a problem. The above is the feeling after watching two plays. The point of view is a little sharp, which will lead to doubts and challenges. Therefore, the author adds that this is only a personal opinion, not a deliberate criticism of the production team of 10 version. Dream of Red Mansions is a big project, which requires the efforts of all kinds of people and all kinds of failures. Only in this way can we be "comprehensive", don't you think?