The reactions of all parties in the SangYuzhu incident.

Sang Yuzhu's "co-creation" is a hidden rule.

Sang Yuzhu said that he recognized the result. He said: "This is a decision made by the organization. I believe that the organization will be responsible for me and I will obey. " However, Sang Yuzhu was dissatisfied with the handling basis. He thinks that the photos he participated in are created by * * *, but they can represent his level and vision.

Regarding the question of "* * * co-creation", Sang Yuzhu said that there have been "hidden rules" in Jilin photography circle for many years. Limited by shooting conditions, everyone often shares a machine. After the shooting, everyone randomly "sliced", and these films are also works created by * * *. In this process, he reached an agreement with grassroots photographers that grassroots photographers can take these works to provincial competitions and he can take these films to national competitions. In the process of appraisal, they are all signed separately.

According to the "work needs", Jilin Federation of Literary and Art Circles, after careful study, decided to remove the post of Deputy Secretary-General of Sang Yuzhu Jilin Photographers Association and no longer preside over the daily work of the Provincial Photographers Association.

Sang Yuzhu, executive vice chairman and deputy secretary general of Jilin Photographers Association. In July 2009, he won the 8th China Photography Award. Since August last year, some people have reported that some of the photos they submitted were suspected of using other people's works. After the matter was reported by the media, it caused widespread concern. After investigation, the organizing committee of the 8th China Photography Award found that Sang Yuzhu's four entries did not conform to the declaration rules when she declared the award, and decided to cancel her award-winning qualification and notify the Jilin Federation of Literary and Art Circles.

On 20 10 65438+ 10 17, the Chinese Photographers Association cancelled Sang Yuzhu's Golden Award because it did not meet the declaration rules. As an administrative organization, the Provincial Federation of Literary and Art Circles can't determine whether the disputed photos are plagiarism or * * * with the same creative nature, and can only organize and deal with them according to the conclusions made by specialized agencies. After research, the Provincial Federation of Literary and Art Circles believes that under the current situation, Sang Yuzhu is no longer suitable to preside over the work of the Provincial Photographers Association, so she is transferred from her original post and no longer serves as the legal representative of the Provincial Photographers Association. Zhao Chunjiang, member and vice chairman of the Provincial Federation of Literary and Art Circles, served as deputy secretary general of the Provincial Photographers Association.

Yang Tingyu introduced that the adjustment of the administrative duties of the Deputy Secretary-General of the Provincial Photographers Association belongs to the purview of the Provincial Federation of Literary and Art Circles. As for whether Sang Yuzhu will continue to serve as the vice chairman of the Provincial Photographers Association, according to the articles of association of the Photographers Association, it needs to be elected by the congress of the Association or the plenary meeting of directors, and the Administration has no right to interfere.

Sang Yuzhu said that as party member, he obeyed the decision of the organization.

Wenbo, Meng Tie

Wenbo is very satisfied with the processing result of Meng Tie.

After many days of downtime, Wenbo finally started at 201010/2 at noon. He said that he was very satisfied with the current results. "This result not only acknowledges the fact that there is a cooperative relationship between the grassroots author and Teacher Sang Yuzhu, but also cancels the award-winning qualification that violates the Oscar judging rules, and also maintains the authority of the Oscar, which is quite good."

Wenbo said that Sang Yuzhu often went to the grassroots to guide him. "At that time, I went up the mountain with him to shoot, and Sang's camera was broken. He borrowed my camera to shoot, and the winning photo is our cooperative work. "

The latest evidence shows that when Wenbo filmed "Sunset Red on Changbai Mountain" from June, 5438 to February, 2003, only Xiaoming and Wenbo were filming together, and there was no Sang Yuzhu at all. In this regard, Wenbo said that he had searched more than 65,438,000 times. In February 2003, he did shoot with Xiao Ming, but he didn't shoot this award-winning work at that time. The winning work was taken with Sang Yuzhu. "This work is different from Xiao Ming's work" Snow Peak "in definition, indicating that the weather is different and it was not taken on the same day."

Meng Tie also expressed satisfaction with the result of handling this matter. He said that he didn't know that the way of group creation was prone to problems. After this incident, he reflected on this and said that he would try to avoid this "hidden rule" in the future.

Xu Lin, Lang Qi.

Xu Linlangqi hopes that the third party will re-investigate.

Xu Lin, the revealer of this plagiarism incident, published a blog post "I have something to say, please answer", questioning the results of the "cooperative works" survey proposed by the China Photography Association. As the organizer and operator of the Academy Awards, it is hard to believe that it is an investigator after the accident. At the same time, it is questioned that the investigation team only published unilateral investigation materials and paid insufficient attention to the new evidence provided by the whistleblower. Xu Lin believes that the survey is unfair, and the conclusion of the survey is still Haicheng.

Lang Qi, the whistleblower of "plagiarism", also holds the above attitude and thinks that "Chinese Photographers Association is partial, conniving and protecting Sang Yuzhu". They hope that the organizing committee can reorganize the investigation, find the third party such as the Federation of Literary and Art Circles to participate, and the stakeholders of the China Photography Association will avoid it.

Shiweibao

The vice chairman of Shaanxi Photographers Association was dissatisfied with the handling of the Golden Award and quit the China Photographers Association.

On the morning of 2 1, Shi Baoxian, vice chairman of Shaanxi Photographers Association, announced his resignation from China Photographers Association and Shaanxi Photographers Association through his blog, expressing his strong disappointment and dissatisfaction with China Photographers Association. In her blog, she said, "The Chinese Photographers Association didn't reflect on its oversight in the scandal of the Golden Awards. Instead, it issued a document to label and slap the critics. Surprise, doubt, disappointment. "