What are the ten inconsistencies between TV plays and history in Yongzheng Dynasty?

There are the following ten inconsistencies:

1, the death of Sun Jiagan.

1) TV series: When Yongzheng sent him to the northwest to offer condolences and assistance, he didn't like Nian Gengyao's arrogance, extravagance and swearing, and was killed by Nian Gengyao.

2) Historically, Sun Jiagan (1683- 1753) lived in the Qianlong Dynasty.

2. The time when Li Hong appeared.

1) TV series: In the forty-six years of Kangxi's Mulan hunting, emperors and grandchildren over ten years old participated. Kangxi appreciated Li Hong and gave the best jade.

2) Historically, Li Hong was born in the 50th year of Kangxi. Li Hong first met his grandfather in July of 6 1 year, and Kangxi died a few months later.

3. Eight lords.

1) TV series: Eight lords is a deep-rooted avenger. In the late Yongzheng period, he tried to restore the "Eight Kings to discuss politics" and forced Yongzheng to abdicate, and helped the third son of Emperor Hongshi ascend to the throne.

2) History: As early as the third year of Yongzheng, the eight lords and nine lords had been dismissed, and Huang Hongshi's three sons were put to death in prison very early.

4. The name of the big eunuch.

1) TV series: Yongzheng's personal eunuch's name is Li Dequan, which was invented by the author.

2) The personal eunuch of Yongzheng in history was named Su Peisheng.

5. E Ertai.

1) TV series: E Ertai didn't appear in the whole play.

2) Historically, E Ertai (1677— 1745) was one of Yong Zhengdi's confidants and an important official in Yongzheng Dynasty.

6, supplemented by official uniforms.

1) TV series: Prince Lian Yunyan, as well as the official uniforms of the four banners owners, use dragons on the front, back and shoulders, but they are not golden dragons like Prince Thirteen.

2) In history, according to the rules of the prince's supplementary service, the dragon should be straight back and forth, and the dragon should walk on both shoulders.

7, the law of eating.

1) TV series: In the palace, Li Wei accompanied Yong Zhengdi for dinner. Li Wei was crying, eating the rice in his mouth and saying encouraging words to the emperor.

2) In the history, the rules of the imperial palace were very strict, and courtiers were not allowed to be so rude in front of the emperor.

8. Dead Eagle Incident.

1) TV series: Kangxi's birthday, a gift to Kangxi on May 14, turned into a dead eagle on May 8.

2) History: In the history of the Dead Eagle incident, Mei did not accompany Kangxi to inspect her mother's grave, so she sent two Haidongqing as an apology. Unexpectedly, she became a dead eagle in Kangxi's hands.

9. Langkodo.

1) TV series: Long Keduo, the ninth magistrate, was Tong Guowei's nephew, who helped Yongzheng seize the throne, and finally forced the palace with the Eight Ye Party and died under house arrest.

2) Historically, Longkeduo was the son of Tong Guowei. Roncodo was proud of his achievements. His men made many mistakes and were implicated in the investigation. Finally, he was imprisoned for life by Yongzheng and died of depression soon.

10, Wu Sidao.

1) TV series: Wu Sidao can be said to be the biggest hero of Yongzheng's victory over Jiuzi. Every time, he was calm, pointed out the mountains and rivers, and used accurate fables to help Yin Zhen win in adversity again and again, and finally retired.

2) Historically, Wu Sidao was only an aide to Tian Wenjing. The greatest hero of Yongzheng's accession to the throne was Huang Hongfa, the 13th elder brother, and his right-hand men were Longkaoduo and Nian Gengyao.

Extended data:

During the Yongzheng period, Nian Gengyao and Li Jue were both coated slaves in Yongzheng's hiding place and were regarded as domestic slaves for generations. Later, due to Yongzheng's esteem, he began to make a fortune. However, the status of Nian Gengyao and Li Jue in real history is far higher than that of coated slaves.

Nian Gengyao, a native of the Yellow Banner of the Eight Banners Han Army, is a serious official of the Eight Banners, not a slave. When his father was young, he went to be the governor of Huguang, acting as the governor of Huguang. He was a famous government official.

Nian Gengyao is better than his father. At the age of 2/kloc-0, he was awarded Jishi Shu (senior reserve cadre in Ming and Qing dynasties). In the forty-eighth year of Kangxi (1709), Nian Gengyao was promoted to the governor of Sichuan, and he was only thirty years old this year. It is worth mentioning that the governor level is equivalent to today's provincial party secretary.

Although Li Wei's background is not as prominent as Nian Gengyao's, it is also unusual. He is the son of a big family in Fengxian County, Jiangsu Province. At the age of 30, his family donated money to Li Wei to be the foreign minister.

But no one expected that Li Wei had done this "soy sauce" sinecure so well and made great achievements. As a result, he has been re-used, and has successively held important positions such as doctor in transfer department, Yanyou Road in Yunnan, Shangshu in household department, Governor in Zhejiang, Shangshu in Ministry of War, Shangshu in Ministry of Punishment, and Governor in Zhili.

Say that finish Nian Gengyao and Li Jue, let's talk about a wonderful plot during the Yongzheng period, that is, the "Eight Ye Party" Yu Yun, Yu Yun and others United several iron hat kings, and proposed to restore the "Eight Kings' proposal", which drove Yong Zhengdi to the wall. Later, the conspiracy of Yunyun and others was defeated, and those who participated in the forced palace were also liquidated by Yongzheng.

However, in real history, there has never been a joint forced palace. In the fourth year of Yongzheng (1726), Yunchan and Yunchan were taken away by Yong Zhengdi for an excuse and imprisoned in Zongren House. Soon after, they died suddenly, and the cause of death was unknown.

Another obvious mistake of Yongzheng Dynasty was that Yong Zhengdi's third brother, Prince Yun Zhi, always played the role of a good man. In fact, King Yun participated in the struggle for the throne when Emperor Kangxi was alive, so he was always regarded as a thorn in Yong Zhengdi's side. Shortly after Yongzheng ascended the throne, Yun Zhi rushed to the Qing Dongling to guard the mausoleum for Emperor Kangxi. In the eighth year of Yongzheng (1730), Yun Zhi was deprived of his title and imprisoned in Yong 'an Pavilion in Jingshan. Two years later, Yun Zhi died of depression.

Li Hong (later Emperor Qianlong) answered Kangxi's questions tactfully at the "Mulan Autumn Festival" in the forty-sixth year of Kangxi, thus winning Kangxi's love. In the real history, Li Hongsheng was born in the 50th year of Kangxi. How could he participate in Mulan Qiu Wei in the 46th year of Kangxi?

Infantry commander Long Keduo is the nephew of Tong Guowei, an important official in the play. In fact, Long Keduo is Tong Guowei's third son. It is worth mentioning that Yong Zhengdi did not grow up with his biological mother Wu Yashi when he was a child, but was raised by Tong Jiashi, the imperial concubine of Emperor Kangxi (Empress Xiao Yiren). Tong Jiashi was Ronkedo's sister, so Yong Zhengdi always called him Uncle Ronkedo.

In addition, there are some obvious mistakes about the death time of Yong Zhengdi's biological mother Wu Yashi and the identity of Li Dequan, the great eunuch around Yong Zhengdi. But these mistakes are harmless and can be ignored if they are not too serious.