Experts consult this year's college entrance examination composition: how to write an article without reading books and newspapers

Ming Ming said that as far as the composition of college entrance examination in all parts of the country this year is concerned, the highest evaluation is Shanghai's click to view the weather forecast volume of Shanghai and more cities-"I want to hold your hand", and the topic is mature; Followed by Beijing, click on the "symbol of Beijing" to view the weather forecast of Beijing and more cities, with obvious regional characteristics; Guangdong's "Carving Angels in My Heart" is also very good.

The lowest evaluation is Swift in Jiangxi to lose weight, followed by click in Tianjin to view the weather forecast volume "Vision" in Tianjin and more cities and the topic composition "Live with fun, live without fun" in Zhejiang. Experts agree that the essay questions in these three provinces are deliberately setting obstacles to the exam. Teacher Sun said that, for example, the proposer may have seen this layer, so he explained the word "vision", which means "the prospect he yearns for". Why beat around the bush? Why not just call it "the prospect I yearn for".

Some experts think that the topic of "People and Road" published in Jiangsu this year is moderately difficult, but the topic is too old. Old questions are prone to plagiarism in disguise and reciting compositions.

At the meeting, the experts also put forward suggestions for the future college entrance examination composition proposition. Ling Huanxin, president of Jiangsu Writing Society and a professor at Nanjing Normal University, said that the composition of the college entrance examination should be flexible and selective, so that students can have something to say and be creative, but also restrictive and prescriptive, so as to reflect the fairness and justice of the examination.

"Famous schools" submit to books.

Professor Pei Xiansheng believes that students' life and knowledge accumulation should be paid attention to in college entrance examination composition. Do students study hard? Is it intentional or insensitive? High school graduates are adults and should reflect on life. In some counties, students are not allowed to read books, newspapers and watch TV, which isolates education from life. Students have no contact with life at all. How can they have their own views and opinions on life? Writing an article is not only the expression of language, but the combination of instrumentality and humanity.

Speaking of students' language poverty and the consequences of studying hard, Professor Pei Xiansheng gave two examples. A graduate student wrote a 120-word leave note with more than 20 typos. An undergraduate wrote a letter, and the recipient on the envelope said "from Grandpa XXX". The envelope was addressed to the postman, but the recipient was the writer's grandfather. Isn't this also about the postman's grandfather?

Yu Xuchu, a special teacher, said that now is an open era of networking and globalization. The college entrance examination essay questions should guide students to pay attention to society, but there are too few questions that really pay attention to society now. This is actually a question of being a man. Students' life is too narrow and they have no reading comprehension ability. Nowadays, many "so-called famous schools completely submit to books" is actually the sorrow of education.

Professor Pei Xiansheng believes that these are the consequences of exam-oriented education. Everyone has been forced into the college entrance examination, and the result will be, as said in this year's Jiangsu college entrance examination composition, "there are many people walking, but there is no road."

It is suggested to improve the composition score

Students lack life experience and language, which is the knowledge of experts attending the meeting. How to solve this problem? Pei Xiansheng, Ling Huanxin and Yu Xuchu are all in favor of increasing the proportion of compositions aimed at examining students' comprehensive Chinese level in Chinese test papers, and the score of composition questions will be increased from 60 to 70.

Professor Ling Huanxin said that at present, both Shanghai and Fujian have raised their composition scores to 70. There are two arrangements for extra 10 points. First, test an essay, and raise the score from 60 to 70; The second is divided into big composition and small composition. 60 points for a large composition, which comprehensively reflects students' language level, and 0 points for a small composition/kloc-0, which examines students' basic skills, such as asking students to write an applied essay.