Weather, stag weather

In most people's minds, because of the interpretation of legends and literary works. I think Han Xin is a great strategist, a wise general and a soldier fairy. Xiang Yu, on the other hand, is a reckless man who only knows the courage of men and has no idea what the art of war is.

In real history, Han Xin's military capability is beyond doubt. Xiang Yu is not only skilled in martial arts, but also talented in military affairs, no less than Han Xin.

In fact, with a little brain, you can infer what Xiang Yu relies on from common sense. The courage of a man? The idea of winning is not desirable. No matter how brave Xiang Yu is, he is also flesh and blood, covered in iron. How many nails can he twist?

Besides, anyone with a little military knowledge knows that leading a war is a rigorous systematic project. Weather, geography, logistics and morale will all lead to failure, and there can be no mistakes. Xiang Yu won again and again, and it is impossible to fight alone. Obviously, Xiang Yu's statement that he is a headstrong man is a literary deduction. Xiang Yu should have received strict education and systematic knowledge, otherwise he would not be so outstanding on the battlefield.

Ban Gu, a historian of the Eastern Han Dynasty, summed up the famous military strategists in the Han Dynasty and divided them into four categories: military strategist, military strategist, military yin and yang strategist and military technologist. Military strategists are Sun Wu and Han Xin. The representative figure of a military strategist is Xiang Yu.

Ban Gu said in the book:? The situation, much thunder and little rain, the latecomers arrive first, the clutch goes home, the situation is changeable, and the enemy is also controlled by minor illnesses. ? In today's words, it is to defeat the enemy with subtle tactics. As a representative figure among military strategists, Xiang Yu is indeed an unprecedented tactical master.

Throughout Xiang Yu's battlefield career, it is almost perfect tactically, and it is difficult to pick out his leisure time. From the Battle of Julu, the Battle of Pengcheng to the Battle of Gaixia, there are field battles, tough battles, pursuit wars and offensive wars, all of which are perfect classics. No matter what kind of terrain and what kind of enemy you face, you can accurately estimate the enemy's situation and adopt the right tactics, which will be broken with one blow. For example, in the Battle of Gaixia:

To tell the truth, every time I look at Tai Shigong's description of the Battle of Gaixia. I always feel that Xiang Yu's defeat in this battle is glorious, just like the wolf trying to escape the tiger and the wolf; The tiger at the end of the road is exhausted and scarred, but it is still majestic.

At this time, Liu Bang almost occupied the whole world, with sufficient troops and high morale. Among them, Liu Bang's newly formed cavalry unit has far exceeded that of Xiang Yu. Liu Bang assembled 600,000 troops, then handed over the military power to Han Xin, a military scientist, and besieged Xiang Yu.

Xiang Yu almost lost all his territory and lost on the battlefield one after another. Most soldiers in the army were injured, lacking medical care and medicine, weapons were destroyed, food and grass were insufficient, and morale was low. At this time, there are only100000 people left.

Han Xin, the army elite three hundred thousand. Han Xin personally directed 300,000 troops to attack Xiang Yu, which was the only direct meeting between Han Xin and Xiang Yu.

Xiang Yu met Shuaijun when he saw Han Xin's attack. The two sides broke out in other places, and Han Xin was breached by Xiang Yu, so we had to retreat. However, other Liu Bang troops attacked behind Xiang Yu's flank, so Xiang Yu had to lead the troops to retreat.

It is hard to imagine that Han Xin's strength is several times that of Xiang Yu; Xiang Yu's army is still a tired teacher and surrounded. Han Xin was abruptly defeated by Xiang Yu, no suspense. The horizontal arrangement and operational command of Han Xin and Xiang Yu are clear at a glance.

I really doubt that it was spread like a spell, okay? Ambush on all sides? Whether there is such a thing. What if Han Xin has the ability to produce such a powerful cloth? Ambush on all sides? Why can't you win several times the strength?

Later, Guan Ying's cavalry pursued Xiang Yu by virtue of its strength, but it was always countered by Xiang. If Xiang Yu didn't want to go back to Jiangdong, Xiang Yu would have succeeded.

Tactically, Xiang Yu is impeccable. Although Han Xin is regarded as one of the representatives of Machiavelli, Han Xin did not do well in Machiavelli. Machiavellian is actually done by Liu Bang's advisers.

At the beginning, in Guanzhong, the household registration information in Guanzhong was collected by Xiao He. Xiang Yu gave up Guanzhong because he didn't see the household registration information of Qin and didn't know the specific wealth of Qin. Later, Sean and Chen Ping bought Xiang Yu's allies and isolated Xiang Yu. Han Xin did nothing in these places, which led to Xiang Yu's defeat.

On the contrary, Xiang Yu's emotional intelligence and politics have been criticized and actually crushed Han Xin.

The humiliation of Han Xin's leg is actually no big deal. That's just a bully. Han Xin, who has martial arts skills, beat him up. At that time, beating and being beaten were very common. Han Xin walked on somebody else's leg with a sword in his hand, and did not dare to resist. Han Xin's understanding of the world is questionable.

Later, Han Xin joined the army for many years, and he was not famous. At that time, the war was chaotic, and those who could fight easily stood out. But Han Xin just couldn't find a chance to express himself, and didn't even have a friend. When Xiao He chased Han Xin under the moon, Han Xin was alone and didn't even have a runner.

Han Xin was later suspected and imprisoned until his death, and no one stood up for him. It can be seen that Han Xin's IQ and talent are good, but his EQ is really poor. None of the old employees who fought alongside him for many years did anything for him after his death, and all went their separate ways.

Xiang Yu is not good at emotional intelligence and politics. But from beginning to end, there are followers.

Xiang seized the opportunity to kill and successfully seized the military power. You can also capture the princes alive and destroy Qin together. It can be seen that Xiang Yu is not ignorant.

Xiang Yu is very attractive, emotional and human to his own people. In the end, nothing can be done. There are still so many people following him that they would rather die than regret it.

To sum up, we can draw such a conclusion. Xiang Yu is inferior to Han Xin in military aspect in strategic layout; Tactically, we can beat Han Xin firmly. In employing people, Xiang Yu is also superior to Han Xin; If a team is formed, Xiang Yu's team can surpass Han Xin in loyalty. If the two fight fairly, Han Xin's chances of winning are worrying.