If Zhuge Liang attacked Wu Dong and Liu Bei defended Shu, would the battle of Yiling be disastrous? Why?

First of all, careful people will find out. When Liu Bei was alive, if there was a big battle, he almost always fought it by himself, unless the soldiers went out or he was too busy. When Liu Bei was alive, Zhuge hardly led troops to fight, except for Shuai Jun who went to Shu to support Liu Bei. So will Liu Bei let him lead the battle of Yiling?

In the battle of Yiling, Liu Bei not only continued to let Zhuge dominate Chengdu's internal affairs, but even Zhao Yun, who opposed the attack on Jiangdong, was arranged as a reserve team in Jiangzhou and did not participate in direct combat.

What I want to say here is that even if Zhuge sent troops to Yiling to fight Lu Xun, the most likely result would be confrontation. As a result, both sides got bored, and then they stopped fighting.

Because Lu Xun and Zhuge are both people who never take risks. Although Zhuge was cautious, Lu Xun did not scatter eagles until he saw rabbits. At that time, the material supply in Jiangdong was not only sufficient, but also the water transportation was convenient, so it was difficult for your Shu army. Coupled with the hot weather, there is Jiangling camp behind Jiangdong, and the Shu army belongs to the expeditionary force, so the logistics support is inconvenient. At the same time, the Shu army had to arrange for the water army to camp against the current in the Three Gorges area, in case Cao Pi took the opportunity to intervene and cut off the Shu army's back road.

The canyon area in Yiling area is not suitable for the expansion of the Corps. If Zhuge goes out before, he will definitely be lured by Lu Xun, and the most dangerous place Lu Xun will definitely close the door and wait for your flaw to appear, just like the law in Dingjun Mountain. Lu Xun is just like Lv Meng dealing with Cao Cao at ruxu Pier. Zhuge certainly did not dare to go deep into dangerous places for a long time.

Unlike Liu Bei, who is an emperor, no one dares to accuse his army of failure. If Zhuge is defeated, the consequences will be extremely unfavorable, so Zhuge will not stay in a dangerous place for long. The final result is estimated that after a period of confrontation, Zhuge quit. But it is difficult for Lu Xun to take advantage of this.

To say the least, even if Zhuge wins, it will not be easy. Jiangdong has long been interested in taking Jingzhou. Taking Jingzhou requires not only the fighting spirit of Zhuge and Lu Xun, but also the engagement between the two armies. The end result is that if either side wins, both sides need to lose and lose strength.

Can only achieve xelloss. If you occupy Jingzhou, you need to be holed up, and you will become a thorn in Jiangdong's side. Will the second Guan Yu come into being? Besides, even if Lu Xun doesn't lure the enemy in, how much offensive power does Jiangling's city defense need from Shu army and Zhuge?

At that time, Zhou Yu led troops to attack Jiangling for a year, and finally Coss was forced to give up Jiangling because of the impassability of food routes. Even if Zhuge went deep into Jiangling, wouldn't he be afraid of Xiangyang Heavy Corps behind him? Not afraid of the defense regiment of Wancheng? Does Zhuge have the ability to create the miracle that Lu Meng and Lu Xun won Jiangling without bloodshed?