Which is better, Shabi Island, Huan Tan Island and Mermaid Island?

I don't know if you want to travel for a day or stay for one night. Do you have children?

In fact, there is no water sports on either island. Basically, a one-day tour means snorkeling twice in the morning and afternoon and having a meal at noon. We signed up for Uncle Hong's group. Mermaid Island takes a long time by bus. After arriving on the island, I basically got off the boat and cleaned up for the first time. After coming back, I had a rest after dinner and went snorkeling for the second time. The second time I didn't go directly to the lounge chair to rest, I was still too tired. Come back after snorkeling 15 minutes to pack, and come back by boat at 3: 30. I'm really in a hurry. If the accommodation looks like Hong Shu's mermaid, the lunch at Mermaid Island is not very good. But the advantage is that it didn't take that long by boat, but it was noisy when I went to the mermaid that day.

The scenery of Mermaid Island is very similar to the mountains in Guilin. The surrounding beach is basically an island, but there is no mermaid-like scenery on it, all tropical trees. The accommodation seems quite good. Some cabins look quite new, with air conditioning outside and few people around the beach. It's really comfortable. It's not that noisy. Personally, I think the beach is better than the mermaid's, but there are waves when I go to the beach around that day. The sea near the beach is not very clear. But the water in the snorkeling place is very clear, and the advantage of snorkeling around the beach is that the water in the snorkeling place is very shallow. Sometimes you can stand on rocks or corals so that you can see corals and fish at close range. Moreover, the toilet on the beach is better than the mermaid island in the rain, and the service is very thoughtful. You don't have to bring your own big towel, and there are free drinks when snorkeling. Lunch is much more delicious than mermaid. However, although it takes a long time to circle the beach island without taking a car or a boat, it only takes about 50 minutes. We had a little storm that day, but it was bumpy all the way. Don't be too bumpy.