Is the amoeba management in kazuo inamori suitable for all enterprises?

Many people know that kazuo inamori runs amoeba, and some companies even go to Japan to study, but it is not suitable for all China enterprises. Let's take a concrete look at several key points of this business philosophy:

First, to achieve full participation in the operation. That is, every employee of the company participates in the management of the company and can put forward his own opinions on the operation of the company.

Second, link all personal work with profit assessment so that employees have a clear sense of purpose;

Third, all policies of the company are open and highly transparent;

There are two points behind, which are top-down unified coordination and leadership, as many enterprises do. And I don't think it is suitable for the above three points. Let's analyze one by one:

First of all, full participation is of course good, but on one condition, all employees must have such knowledge level. In China, the knowledge level of many employees is not very high, especially in some enterprises that focus on wage increase manufacturing, and employees have no business awareness at all, which is obviously not acceptable;

Second, the assessment of each employee is combined with profit. This requirement for data reliability is very high, which is difficult to achieve in China. This is one of them. One more thing, in many Internet companies, the profits of some jobs are incalculable. For example, some posts are just drainage, but the profit of draining a fan is difficult to calculate. Even if it can be calculated, in order to calculate this matter, a large number of financial personnel must be added, which undoubtedly increases the cost for many small Internet companies.

Third, the policy is completely transparent. This is not feasible in many industries in China, and the trust of enterprises and employees is very high. We know that the policies of many industries are trade secrets, and once leaked, it will cause great losses to enterprises, so it is a risky thing for many enterprises.

But one thing, his idea of full participation is very good, but we need to change it to the amoeba business model with China characteristics.