The story of wrestling death

■ The news of death came: sudden death after going to the toilet

Chen Xujin died on the third day of New Year's Eve. At about 1 o'clock on February 16th, Zhu Min, the nephew of the deceased, as a representative of his family, was called downstairs after receiving a phone call and got into a car of the Public Security Bureau.

There are three people in the car besides the driver, and two police officers from xiushui county Public Security Bureau and Chengnan Police Station. Zhu Min was told orally that his uncle Chen Xujin died suddenly after falling in xiushui county detention center in the early morning. The police officer said that he got up at about 2 am to go to the toilet, fell down and fainted. After being found by the patrolling police at 5 o'clock, he was sent to xiushui county People's Hospital and died after being rescued.

The police officer also said that Chen Xujin was in poor health. He fainted once in the detention center before, and the doctor checked that it was hypoglycemia. In the past few days, the detention center has improved the life of detainees, and may eat too well and have diarrhea.

45-year-old Chen Xujin is a native of xiushui county, a laid-off worker from the former County Tea Institute. Two years ago, his wife left him without any divorce formalities, and he lived alone after his only daughter got married, which was very poor. Chen works as a deliveryman in a liquor store in the county. As the year approached, Chen Xujin, who was embarrassed, hid the liquor worth more than 6, yuan in the store at home. After being discovered by the boss, he called the police and everyone was caught. On January 4th this year, Chen Xujin was criminally detained by Chengnan Police Station on suspicion of stealing liquor, and was held in No.6 cell of xiushui county Detention Center.

According to the news disclosed after the sudden death, Chen Xujin was approved to be arrested on January 13th. However, family members reported that Chen had never received any relevant notification documents from the time of criminal detention to the arrest. Until the evening of February 11, Chen Xujin called a relative from the detention center, and the relatives knew that he had been arrested. I thought it was missing.

Chen Xujin said on the phone that he didn't have enough to eat in the detention center and asked his relatives to send some money to buy food. On the afternoon of February 13th, Zhu Min and Chen Xujin's younger brother Chen Xiaohua came to the detention center and sent 3 yuan cash and food through a deputy director named Liang, but they didn't see Chen Xujin himself.

Relatives said that Chen Xujin was in good health before his death, and there was no problem in moving the finished wine to the seventh and eighth floors.

■ the first coordination meeting: the county procuratorate intervened in the investigation

Zhu Min, who learned the news of his uncle's death, immediately went to xiushui county funeral home. The eyes of the deceased were open, and there were many striking scars and blood stains on the orbit, forehead, nose bridge and chest, and there was an obvious bruise on the neck.

Zhu Min said, "My first instinct is that my uncle must have been beaten before he died! How can wrestling even have scars on the neck? Moreover, how can a normal person fall to the ground with a positive forehead and nose bridge? Only an action similar to a wall impact can leave such a scar! "

Relatives who came to see the body one after another also expressed doubts and wanted to transfer the body for preservation, but were stopped by dozens of public security policemen who were guarding the funeral home. The situation once intensified. At 3 o'clock in the afternoon, Kuang Jun, deputy secretary of the Political and Legal Committee of xiushui county, presided over the first coordination meeting between relevant departments and representatives of the families of the deceased. Kuang Jun said at the meeting that the xiushui county Procuratorate has been involved in the incident investigation, and Jiujiang City also attaches great importance to this matter, and will send a forensic doctor to come over, hoping that the family members can solve the problem in an orderly manner.

Some family members noticed that the deceased was wearing a red T-shirt, unlike his own clothes, so they proposed to send the clothes of the deceased in the detention center and cremate them with the deceased according to local customs. It was not until 9 o'clock in the evening that the clothes of the deceased were taken out from the detention center by the deceased's brother Chen Xiaohua and brother Chen Haiqing. Coats, autumn clothes, trousers, etc. are not only wet like being soaked in water, but also have several obvious tear marks on the coat.

"Why are clothes wet? The coat was torn, too? " The more puzzled the family members were, the relevant parties explained that Chen Xujin had diarrhea twice that night when the Chinese New Year detention center added meals. "The clothes were wet with diarrhea."

"This is an insult to our IQ. Do you have diarrhea to your shirt?" Chen Jingzhu, the niece of the deceased, suspected that the clothes were washed to destroy the evidence. "When I first saw the body, there was blood on the face of the deceased."

■ Second briefing: The initial diagnosis was myocardial infarction

At 12 o'clock in the middle of the night, Kuang Jun, deputy secretary of the Political and Legal Committee of the county party committee, once again convened relevant departments and five family members to hold the second briefing.

a person in charge of the county procuratorate surnamed Zhang reported the preliminary investigation results at the meeting. He said that after the incident, the county procuratorate set up an investigation team consisting of 1 people. After a day of investigation, the preliminary conclusions are as follows: Chen Xujin's death ruled out violence, and CT examination showed that there was no abnormality in the skull of the deceased; Chen Xujin got up to urinate in the early morning of February 16th, and accidentally wrestled. At about 5: in the morning, the detainees in the same cell found Chen fainted to the ground and were sent to the county people's hospital, where he died after being rescued. After hospital diagnosis, the cause of Chen's death was initially diagnosed as myocardial infarction, and the time of death was 6: 5 am that day.

The family immediately questioned how to explain the injuries on the face and neck of the deceased. Zhang explained that it was caused by a fall.

The next day, the relatives of the deceased submitted a written report on applying to the forensic doctor of Jiangxi Provincial Public Security Department for an autopsy.

■ Autopsy appraisal opinion: The final verdict is "death"

At 3 pm on February 19th, in the presence of four relatives of the deceased, three staff members from Jiangxi Provincial Procuratorate and Provincial Public Security Department and forensic doctors dissected the body.

on the morning of March 1th, the county government called nine relatives of the deceased to publish an autopsy report signed on March 4th.

this 9-page report shows that more than 7 epidermis peeling or subcutaneous bleeding were found on the head, face, trunk and limbs of the deceased. "According to the damage morphology analysis, the body surface injury of the deceased was formed by contact with rough surface objects", and besides the body surface abrasion and contusion, the old contusion was found on the bottom of the brain of the deceased, "it was formed by indirect violent blow, which was in line with the formation of the raised bone ridge caused by direct impact of brain tissue."

Pathological examination at autopsy also found that the deceased had adrenal medullary hyperplasia, chronic pleurisy, chronic bronchitis, chronic interstitial nephritis, enteritis and other diseases before his death. According to the analysis of the report, "Adrenal medullary hyperplasia can lead to excessive secretion of autonomic catecholamine and produce corresponding symptoms. According to the survey, the deceased had symptoms and signs of sudden fainting, dizziness, palpitation, sweating, pale face and rapid heartbeat on February 16, 21, and suddenly fell down on February 16, 21. These symptoms and signs are consistent with the symptoms of adrenal medullary hyperplasia. "

The report's "appraisal opinion" is that Chen Xujin died of heart, lung and other multiple organ system failure due to adrenal medulla hyperplasia and abnormal secretion of catecholamine on the basis of lung and renal insufficiency. Rule out the possibility that the deceased died of mechanical injury, mechanical asphyxia or poison poisoning.

Chen Si, the daughter of the deceased, immediately questioned: How did the injuries on the deceased come from? Kuang Jun, deputy secretary of the Political and Legal Committee of the county party committee, explained: Before Chen Xujin was arrested, the hotel owner had beaten Chen Xujin with beer bottles and umbrellas; On the day of being arrested on January 3, Chen Zeng jumped off the stairs next to his window; On January 26th, Chen Xujin fainted once in the detention center.

Kuang also revealed that on February 16th, the day of the accident, Chen Xujin went to the toilet several times because of diarrhea, and defecated in the trash can in the prison room. The whole room was stinky and was beaten by Chen Mou, the detainee in the same prison room. However, according to the investigation, Chen Mou's beating on Chen Xujin would not kill him. Chen Mou's beating behavior will be dealt with according to relevant laws and regulations.

■ Handling: the director of the county guard was dismissed

The person in charge of the county public security bureau also announced the handling of the relevant personnel in this case: Fan Lianwu, the director of the xiushui county Detention Center, was dismissed; In charge of the police suspended for investigation; The police on duty that day were investigated; The leaders in charge of the public security bureau make a written inspection to the party Committee of the bureau.

On March 1th, the family members of the deceased consulted a judicial appraisal institution about the autopsy report through their lawyers. The feedback from the other party was that the "appraisal opinions" in the autopsy report were not "appraisal conclusions", and the appraisal report was based on the "investigation reflection" of the relevant departments, which was not rigorous and objective, and did not identify the time of death, but only investigated the time of death.

On the afternoon of March 12th, the deceased's younger brother Chen Xiaohua and daughter Chen Si submitted a written application to the xiushui county Procuratorate, asking the investigation team to announce the investigation conclusion of the case to their families, but they were rejected. A deputy procurator-general of the county procuratorate said that after autopsy, the prisoner died of illness, and it is not necessary for the family members to get relevant information; Moreover, without the consent of the county party Committee, according to the discipline of handling cases of procuratorial organs, it shall not be announced to the public.

■ Investigation: The doctor wrote a diagnosis report casually

The diagnosis report of Chen Xujin's "initial diagnosis of death from myocardial infarction" was written by Zhu Chaoyang, director of the Second Department of xiushui county People's Hospital. On March 2, several relatives of the deceased went to the hospital office and medical department to ask for a diagnosis report, and they were told that they had been taken away by the relevant departments.

On March 3, Zhu Chaoyang told reporters on the phone that at about 5: 35 on February 16, Chen Xujin was taken to the hospital, "breathing and heartbeat were gone", but according to hospital regulations, he had to be rescued for half an hour, so the time of death was written at 6: 5.

Zhu said that at that time, someone from the detention center briefed him on the situation of the deceased, and two people from the county public security bureau and the procuratorate respectively came. "At that time, there was nothing we could do. They asked you to write a diagnosis ... They said that everyone was breathing in the detention center, and we were not sure, so we had to tell him."

"I'll write a suspicious myocardial infarction casually, and I can't write anything else. Let me tell you the truth, we can't jump to conclusions without any examination for this kind of person who has no breathing and heartbeat. I am not biased on both sides of this thing, so I can only write one at will according to the situation they reflect, and add a question mark behind it to indicate suspicion. "

Zhu said, "I can't write that it was killed or what it was like without any basis. At that time, let me draw a conclusion, and I can only draw such a conclusion.