"Water Margin" Song Wu returned to Qinghe from Chai Jin Zhuang to visit relatives. Why did he go to Jingyanggang?

This question is very interesting. We might as well discuss it after dinner. There is no need to take it seriously.

As we know, Song Wu first appeared in the villa in Chai Jin. At that time, Song Wu introduced himself, saying that he was from Qinghe County and had fled to Chai Jin Zhuang to take refuge because of a crime.

Let's take a look at these two places.

Chai Jin's manor is located in Cangzhou, which is now near Cangzhou City, Hebei Province.

Qinghe County is located in Qinghe County, Xingtai City, Hebei Province.

As you can see, Cangzhou and Qinghe are actually located in what is now Hebei Province, not far apart. Let's look at the map.

As we can see from the map, Qinghe County is located about 250 kilometers southwest of Cangzhou City.

Then let's see where yanggu county is.

Yanggu county, located in Liaocheng City, Shandong Province. Let's have a look on the map.

From the map, we can see that yanggu county is located about130km south of Qinghe County.

Comparing the three places together, Qinghe County is located in the south of Cangzhou City, and yanggu county is located in the south of Qinghe County. In other words, Qinghe County is located in the middle of Cangzhou and yanggu county. Let's look at the map.

Obviously, if you take the normal route, you don't need to go through yanggu county to go to Qinghe from Cangzhou. In other words, Song Wu took a big detour and took many wrong roads.

This is the famous geographical error in Water Margin.

There are many similar mistakes. For example, how did Song Jiang pass Liangshan when he was sent from Yuncheng County to Jiangzhou? Not on the same line at all.

Why is there such an error? The conclusion of later generations' textual research is that Shi Naian, the author of Water Margin, is from the south. He is not particularly familiar with the north, so he made many geographical mistakes. At the same time, we can see that the author has never made similar mistakes in the relevant chapters of recruiting Fang La. Because the author is from Jiangsu and Zhejiang.

However, this little mistake is harmless and adds a lot of discussion topics to readers.

One day, Song Wu came out of Chai Daguan's manor and went to Qinghe County to visit his eldest brother Wu Dalang. In the afternoon, Song Wu came to a small shop and said, "Xiao Er, bring the wine and two plates of beef". After a while, the bartender set the table and drinks: "Your wine, my Lord, and a plate of peanuts". Song Wu ate a big bowl of wine and chunks of meat. Song Wu has developed limbs, is tall and powerful, and even a bowl of wine is not enough to drink. So he said to the bartender, "Xiao Er, bring the wine." The bartender brought a bowl of wine and Song Wu gulped it down. "Bring a bowl of wine at most." Song Wu drank it dry again and continued to ask the bartender to bring the wine. At this time, the bartender stood beside Song Wu, pointing to the small flag outside the door, which read "Three bowls are not up to standard" and "What bird three bowls are not up to standard? You are surprised that I have no money for you. " Song Wu took out a silver coin from the chain and put it on the table. He said to the bartender, "You just take the wine." Song Wu drank eight bowls of wine in one breath. Song Wu, satiated with food and drink, stood up and stumbled out. "Guest, you can't go here." "What can't I go?" Xiao Er pointed to a line under the banner of Xiao Qi. Song Wu took a closer look: Jingyang County Order said: Recently, a tiger was found in Jingyang Port, constantly hurting pedestrians and businessmen. Send someone to catch it, but it's useless. For the safety of pedestrians, if you want to cross the steel, please group it in the afternoon. Song Wu Zheng in his heart: It seems that the county magistrate of Jingyang County has really come. What should I do? Just now Xiao er complained that three bowls were not allowed to pass the class. If you go back at this time, you will be laughed at. Instead of being laughed at, why not open it and see what the tiger looks like? So, with a heart, Song Wu picked up Fu Bao and set off for the Chaoyang gang.

In "Water Margin", Song Wu Jing Yang Gang hit the tiger and became popular. The original text said that Song Wu was homesick and wanted to go back to Qinghe County to find his brother Wu Dalang. Then why did he walk a long way to the border of yanggu county (Jingyanggang)?

Why did Song Wu go further and further? I think there are three possible reasons.

First, the plot needs. The Water Margin, carefully planned by Shi Naian, is a novel after all, and all the plot arrangements are for the performance of the characters. In order to make the role of Song Wu more vivid and increase the appreciation of the novel, it is understandable that Shi Naian arranged a drama of Jingyang Gangda Tiger Fighting.

Imagine that this tiger fight is arranged in Jingyanggang, which is very close to Qinghe County. It seems reasonable.

Second, Shi Naian is a southerner and is not familiar with the geographical position in the north. Judging from the conquest of Fang La by Liangshan heroes, Shi Naian's description of the south can be said to be exquisite! In particular, the geographical mountains and rivers, waterside pavilions and terraces in Hangzhou are described vividly, with few loopholes.

On the contrary, his description of the north can't stand scrutiny. For example, Lin Chong's description of the cold weather in the north at Yeshan Temple makes you feel that he is not from the north.

Therefore, I think there are many reasons why Shi Naian's geographical concept is wrong.

Third, Song Wu didn't make a good plan on the way. If it weren't for the author's arrangement or mistake, maybe the protagonist Song Wu is a road idiot. He was anxious to go home to see his brother, but forgot how to take the fastest route to Qinghe County.

Think of a word to share with you and say:

We should not only bow our heads and pull the cart hard, but also look up at the road ahead. * * * with everyone.

Starting from Cangzhou, Song Wu could have gone straight to Qinghe, but he accidentally strayed into Yanggu, which led to the scene of Jingyanggang killing tigers. Since then, he has made a name for himself and established the title of great hero. It is also a coincidence!

Again, this is just a novel, don't get to the bottom of it, it's boring. The above is my humble opinion, welcome to interact.

end

Ordinary people also have trails. Pay attention to ordinary trails and read China's classics.

Song Wu didn't go the wrong way, because Qinghe County written in Water Margin is Qinghe County in Shandong, not Qinghe County in Hebei.

But there was no Qinghe county in Shandong in history, and Qinghe county must be in Xingtai, Hebei Province today. Nevertheless, Song Wu did not go the wrong way. He returned from Chai Jinzhuang to visit relatives in Qinghe County, passing through Jingyanggang in yanggu county.

Why is this?

Where is Jingyanggang in Water Margin? It is clearly recorded in the book that Song Wu killed a tiger in yanggu county, Dongping Prefecture, Shandong Province. The name of this post is "Jingyanggang". This should be beyond doubt. But can Jingyanggang hide tigers?

Many readers question whether Jingyanggang can hide tigers. I don't think it's possible to hide the tiger now. Could it be that the geology has changed now? Maybe Jingyanggang was a high mountain in those days.

There is no need to discuss whether Jingyanggang can hide tigers. Because, Shi Naian just borrowed this place name and wrote another story. So, what story is hidden in Shi Naian's Song Wu Da Hu?

The word "Jingyang" appeared in the other two stories except Jingyanggang, where Song Wu fought a tiger. These two stories are that Gao Qiu and Cai Jing asked Song Huizong to send troops to conquer Liangshan in the early years. There is a description in these two stories: the next day, at five o'clock, in the leaking yard, I waited for the Jingyang bell to ring; The next day, at the fifth watch, the bell of Jingyang rang, and all the civil and military officials gathered in the yard.

It turns out that "Jingyanggang" in Water Margin is here, which is a metaphor for the Forbidden Palace.

Since Jingyanggang is just a borrowed place name, what does it matter whether Qinghe County is in Shandong or Hebei? Qinghe county should also be a borrowed place name, which, like Jingyanggang, hides other things or meanings.

I think "Qinghe" means "Christina", just by reading the history of the Northern Song Dynasty hidden in Water Margin. Song Wu killed the tiger in Jingyanggang. Of course, it was "the world is peaceful and there is nothing in all directions".

Because, the same is written in the early dynasty, held in Jiayou at three o'clock on the third day of March, and Shi Naian didn't write "Jingyang Bell". Although there were demons in the Song Renzong dynasty, Shi Naian praised Song Renzong's first 27 years after he succeeded to the throne as a "three-liter world". The world was prosperous, the roads were not picked up, and the households stayed up all night.

In the different writing methods of three sessions, there is a "Jingyanggang" in the middle, and the meaning of Qinghe County is self-evident.

The question is, since a place name like Jingyang was found in yanggu county, why should Qinghe County be added? Shi Naian can't write a real-name land, can it also be used as a metaphor for "world peace"?

This matter, but also from yanggu county.

Qinghe county in the water margin is the neighboring county of Dongping prefecture. Shi Naian must be very familiar with the geographical location of Shandong. So there are three details about Qinghe County in the book.

Song Wu met Song Jiang in Chai Daguan Village. When Chai Jin introduced Song Wu to Song Jiang, he said: This man is from Qinghe County. Here, there is no mention of where Qinghe County is. This is Shi Naian's "Cunning", which was deliberately written for Song Wu's "Lost" and led readers to the secret story of Jingyanggang Dahu.

Next, this book was written several times in Qinghe County, which has no state capital. Shi Naian seems to emphasize this point repeatedly to remind readers. When Song Wu "detoured" to yanggu county, he was probably stunned by Shi Naian.

Since coming to yanggu county, Song Wu no longer "hides" his hometown. He said to the shopkeeper at Sanwanbugang Hotel: I am from Qinghe County. I have been to this Jingyang Mountain at least 10, 20 times. When did I hear there was a big bug?

Look, Song Wu is from Shandong. He went back to Qinghe County to visit relatives, and must pass through Jingyanggang, yanggu county.

After killing the tiger, Song Wu introduced himself to the big family and hunters at the foot of the mountain, and said: The villain is from Qinghe County, a neighboring county ... who came back from Cangzhou. According to the book, yanggu county is in Dongping Prefecture, and Qinghe County is a county adjacent to Dongping Prefecture. So "Qinghe County" is not written in Qinghe County, Hebei Province, even if it is not in Shandong Province.

Yanggu county liked this tiger hero very much, so he left Song Wu to be the county magistrate of Yanggu on the grounds that "although you are originally from Qinghe County, yanggu county is just close at hand with me".

So repeatedly write the relationship between Qinghe County and yanggu county, Shi Naian is actually making up a "Qinghe County", or the moral mentioned above. Moreover, it seems that for fear that later readers don't know what it means, it is futile to get the fictional "Qinghe County" to Hebei.

But the question is, since Shi Naian wrote a real name of yanggu county, why do you want to make a virtual Qinghe County? Why can't you make a virtual county town and put an unknown Jingyanggang (or virtual) in this fictional place?

I'm afraid I really can't. The story of fighting tigers in the Song Dynasty is far more than writing the "Jingyang Bell" in the Northern Song Dynasty.

"Jingyanggang" is actually in the Bauhinia City of Daming. I have read the story of Water Margin in many articles. More importantly, it is a metaphor for the history of the Ming Dynasty, hiding the mystery of "Jingnan War" and Wen Jian. Among them, the story of "Song Wu killed her sister-in-law" secretly wrote about the death of Xu Da and the fact that Emperor Jianwen cut the princes. Therefore, the story of Song Wu killing a tiger must have happened in yanggu county.

Let's start with "Jingyanggang". There was a Jiming Temple near Nanjing Bauhinia City in the Ming Dynasty, and there was a Jingyang Building at the top of Jiming Temple. This building was built in the Southern Song Dynasty and is now a part of Jiming Temple. After Judy succeeded to the throne, Yao, the prime minister who instigated the Jing Nan War, lived in Jiming Temple.

In the Water Margin, Yao is compared with some characteristics of "Men", "Men" and others. Among them, the two news of "Soap Cloth Straight" and "Tiger Face Walker" correspond to the Prime Minister and Yao who is "like a sick tiger".

The word "Jiming Temple" also appeared in Water Margin. Shi Naian, a wonderful rooster who moved to Zhujiazhuang to announce the dawn, wrote the story of the battle of Jingnan when Judy entered the city, and hid the mystery of his whereabouts in Three Zhujiazhuang.

I have repeatedly interpreted the metaphor of the story of Zhujiazhuang, so I will mention it here.

Jingyang gang killed the tiger, but in fact, "lowering the dragon to lure the tiger" alluded to the launch of the Jingnan campaign. It formed a chain relationship with the story that happened in yanggu county, followed by the hidden writing of "cutting the vassal".

Song Wu killed his sister-in-law, and wrote to Wen Jian to cut the princes. I have also read Wang Po Pan Jinlian's statement that "Chinese New Year is exactly 93 years old", so I won't go into details here. However, when it comes to why Shi Naian wrote Jingyanggang in yanggu county, we have to mention Ximen Qing in the story of Song Wu killing his wife.

In A.D. 1402, Judy came to Nanjing from Zhenjiang ("Jiangzhou"). Yi zhu and Li Jinglong, who were guarding Jinchuan Gate, saw Judy's umbrella cover outside the city and opened the gate to welcome Yan Jun into the city.

When Judy entered Nanjing, the soldiers guarding the city had knelt on the roadside and shouted "Long live". This is a premeditated rebellion against Emperor Wen Jian. Zhu Yi, who opened Jinchuan Gate, was named the Valley King by Zhu Yuanzhang in 139 1 year.

"Valley" king, Li "Jing" long, this is probably the yanggu county and Jingyanggang. Jinchuanmen is the northwest gate of Nanjing. Judy entered Nanjing through this gate, and the battle of Nanjing was declared victory. Isn't it worth celebrating?

This answer can only interpret yanggu county and Jingyanggang so concisely, and these historical secrets are hidden in other stories in the book.

The battle of Jingnan was fought for four years, but the world was out of harmony and the people were miserable. In the preface of the Water Margin, it is written that "people are happy and peaceful, and the flowers can't sleep", and the ending of the battle of Jingnan has returned to the peaceful era of "Haiyan and Heqing".

From the story relationship with Lu, Lu and Lin Chong, it can be seen that all three of them will appear in the Bianjing Defence War to fight against the nomads from the same time because of the prophetic poem "Guo Jing meets the hero", showing the true story of "Jingyang Gang hits the tiger".

On his way home to see his brother Wu Dalang, Song Wu happened to meet a liquor store. Men like to drink several times, but it happened that there were three bowls of words written on the signboard of this restaurant, which aroused Song Wu's aggressive psychology. Only Song Wu walked into the store and drank three bowls. He didn't get drunk, but continued to ask for wine from the restaurant. The shopkeeper was helpless and moved all the wine to Wu Erlang. He even drank 18 bowls, and his mind was still clear. I have to admire it. After drinking the wine, it was already dark at night, and Song Wu was anxious to go home and prepare to leave. At this time, the bartender insisted on preventing Song Wu from going to Shanggang and told him that there was a kind of blade on Jingyanggang, which was specially used to eat people. Song Wu didn't believe this, thinking that the bartender suspected that he had eaten a lot of wine in the shop and told stories to scare himself. So I took my luggage and went to Jingyanggang without hesitation. Song Wu walked to Jingyanggang in such a crooked way. He was a little tired on the way, so he fell asleep on the stone and ignored the bartender's words completely. Just as he was sleeping, a big bug appeared. Maybe the hero will take care of him. Song Wu suddenly became sober, and immediately calmed down and threw himself into the battle with the blade. Finally, he successfully killed Blade and met his brother Wu Dalang in yanggu county.

In fact, this was limited by the conditions in Shi Naian at that time, and there may be some geographical deviations, which is completely understandable. No matter Shi Naian, Luo Guanzhong and Wu Cheng'en, they are just literati, not geographers, so it is normal that they are not familiar with the geographical location.

In fact, this geographical mistake was also made in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms. For example, Guan Yu's route of going through five passes and beheading six generals is totally illogical according to the position of modern geography.

Pang Tong died in Phoenix Slope, but there is no such place as Phoenix Slope. Readers should be serious, and they will be in big trouble. Can you say that Lao Luo was thoughtless and cheated?

Similarly, Shi did not deliberately study the geographical location. In addition, most of the plot of Water Margin may come from folk stories, fiction, or a little historical exaggeration and romance. The stories of Song Wu, Wu Da and Pan Jinlian are all illusory, which is not realistic in geography and can be understood. Of course, it will not affect the wonderful novels.

In addition, it was not so convenient to look at the map at that time. Now there is an electronic map on the Internet, which can be easily found.

Another possibility is whether the place name has changed. Are there still several places with the same name?

None of the above can rule out the possibility!

Where are so many reasons? If you ask the reason, you should also ask the author, just like we write a composition. Why do you write like this? Just because of what you wrote, I think your composition score can be as simple as a little higher.

Just a novel. There is nothing wrong with writing right or wrong. In Harry Potter, passers-by can walk through walls. Why aren't they surprised? Just read, don't study it as a book.

I'm drunk. I didn't navigate and went the wrong way.

First of all, I got lost. Second, I didn't ask the way. The toll was pointed in the wrong direction.