Common sense mistakes in Jin Yong's novels

1. What common sense mistakes did Jin Yong make?

I like reading books since I was a child, especially martial arts novels when I was a child.

Jin Yong is a great writer who enjoys a high reputation at home and abroad. The influence of his works is so great that there are so many readers that almost no one can match it. His work "The Story of Snow Shooting White Deer Plain and Laughing at Peach Blossom Man" was read in junior high school, and many chapters can be memorized from beginning to end.

Recently, once in a while, combining other historical materials, I found some ridiculous common sense mistakes in the history of science and technology. I'll make some notes for your reference. I believe that these minor faults will not damage the "internal strength" of the financier. 1. Episode 16 of "Eternal Dragon Slayer": "(Zhang Wuji) picked some unknown fruits from the bush and held them in his hand. He smelled a sweet smell and took a bite, which made it more delicious. Peaches are not so crisp, apples are not so sweet, and pears are not so greasy. "

According to historical records, apples originated in southeastern Europe, Asia Minor and the South Caucasus, and were introduced to China at the end of Yuan Dynasty. At that time, they could only be enjoyed in the court. Zhang Wuji was a teenager at the bottom of society, so he couldn't have eaten apples.

Therefore, it is impossible for Zhang Wuji to compare the unheard-of "apple" with "nameless fruit", and of course he will not know that "apple is not so sweet". Second, the sixth episode of "The Condor Heroes": "He (Yang Guo) has been wandering in the Jianghu since he was a child, and he really knows how to find something to eat. Looking around, he saw a big piece of corn growing on the western hillside, so he picked five sticks.

The corn is not ripe yet, but it can be eaten. "Corn is not a native crop in China.

Native to America, 1494 was introduced to Europe after Columbus returned from America, and 16 was introduced to China in the middle of the century (the earliest record of corn now is the thirty-ninth year of Jiajing in the Ming Dynasty (1560). At the end of the Southern Song Dynasty, Yang Guo wanted to find a cornfield on the hillside of Shaanxi, which was simply daydreaming.

It will take at least three or four hundred years to find it. Third, the first episode of "Legend of the Condor Heroes": "(Song San) slowly scalded two pots of yellow wine, and produced a plate of broad beans, a plate of salted peanuts, a plate of dried tofu and three salted eggs."

"Yang Tiexin see a pot of wine has been finished, it is a pot, three people will lambaste Qin Gui. The lame man brought another dish of broad beans and peanuts. "

"Sometimes, the two will go to a small hotel to drink a few pots, and the lame Qu San will also make soju and bring drinks such as broad beans and peanuts." The author casually wrote broad beans, peanuts and pumpkin seeds into ordinary drinks here. He didn't know that all three crops were actually imported.

Broad beans, also known as beans, cold beans and arhat beans, were introduced to China from Persia in the Yuan Dynasty and were widely planted in the Ming Dynasty. Peanut and pumpkin are crops from America, which began to spread outside America after Columbus discovered the New World.

Peanut was introduced to China much later than broad bean, and it was introduced to China about 1530 years ago. It took a long time for it to spread from the coast to the inland areas. Until the last years of Qianlong, peanuts were still precious things in banquets, which were difficult for ordinary people to eat. This is 1 199. In a small shop in a poor rural area in Lin 'an, the lame man Qu San served food (broad beans and peanuts) imported from Persia and America as dishes. Guo Xiaotian and Yang Tiexin were not surprised by this strange novelty, which even the emperor at that time had never seen. According to common sense, the two heroes should at least have a drink for Qu San: "That lame man!" " Did it fall from the sky? "4. There is also a plot in" Eight Dragons ":the old hero Xiao Yuanshan also brought some peanuts to his son Feng Xiao as a drink.

Peanuts were not introduced to China until at least four or five hundred years later. I really don't know where the heroes written by Xiao Lao in the Northern Song Dynasty came from. Fifth, the eleventh time of "Tianlong Babu": "Since then, all the way to the east, for more than 20 days, Duan Yu listened to the accent of passers-by, and gradually felt elegant and soft, and there was no pepper in the dish."

Obviously, the author thinks that Yunnan, Guizhou, Sichuan and Hunan all like peppers, but peppers, like corn, peanuts, pumpkins and tobacco, are all American agricultural products, which were introduced to China in the late Ming Dynasty. The traditional spice in China is not pepper, but mainly pepper.

Moreover, pepper was only used as an ornamental plant at first, and then it was used as a dish. According to historical records, the earliest time for Guizhou and Hunan to eat Chili was during the Qianlong period of the Qing Dynasty, but it was generally after Daoguang in the Qing Dynasty that they began to eat Chili. The novel "Dragon and Eight Branches" is written in the era of Song Zhezong, so when Duan Yu went all the way east, it was not that there was no pepper in the dish, but that the locals had never seen pepper, and of course they had never eaten it.

6. In Tianlong Babu, Duan Yu also drank Biluochun tea, which appeared 600 years later, in Yanziwu, Suzhou. Biluochun, formerly known as "scary fragrance", has been a treasure in tea since ancient times and is said to have a history of 1300 years.

In the thirty-eighth year of Kangxi in Qing Dynasty (AD 1699), Emperor Kangxi visited Taihu Lake in the south, and the governor gave it tea. Emperor Kangxi thought the name was too vulgar and renamed it "Biluochun". Duan Yu should drink "scary incense". At that time, there would never be the name "Biluochun".

Seven, "Dragon Eight Branches" Chapter 24 "There is an old alliance in the cloud beside the candle": Xiao Feng can't see it clearly. After listening to her words, she opened the window and walked into the room with bright lights. Looking at it, I can't help shivering slightly. I saw Mrs. Ma's shoulders, arms, chest and thighs were covered with knives, and the wounds were covered with ants. In the first part of this plot, the author explained the season at that time: "I think the charcoal fire on the kang is burning vigorously, and the button in Mrs. Ma's neck is loose, revealing a white neck and the top edge of a red silk tube.

The two candles lit on the kang are white, and the red candle shines on her red cheeks. It's windy and snowy outside, but spring blossoms in the bucket. "

There is no doubt that it was winter. While ants are hibernating animals, A Zi obviously can't find ants.

Mrs. Ma's "wound is covered with ants" can only be the author's wishful thinking. At this time, the ants are hibernating deep in the stratum, and A Zi's "command" can't be heard if he wants to hear it. Eight, "Dragon Eight Branches" wrote in the twenty-sixth chapter "Kill the bear and kill the tiger with bare hands": "I hurried for several months, winter went to spring, and Ah Zi ate ginseng every day, and my injury improved quite a bit.

The ginseng that Jurchen dug up in the barren hills is the top grade for many years, really.

Please list the mistakes in Jin Yong's martial arts novels.

There are too many mistakes! ! ~~~

I once read an article devoted to the mistakes in his novels.

Remember these?

& amplt； Shooting Sculpture & gt There is a passage describing Huang Rong cooking tomatoes for Hong Qigong, but tomatoes are "favorite apples", which makes people afraid to eat them for a long time. It should have been introduced from abroad in the Ming Dynasty.

& amplt； Liancheng tactic &; gt； The description of snow sealing for more than half a year violates meteorological common sense II.

What I don't understand most is, where do people in Wulin get the money to wander the Jianghu without paying? I watched Shenzhen Satellite TV a while ago&; lt； February River debated Jin Yong > February, and he mentioned this problem and said, "Teacher Jin is really a genius. Where did the money from Huang Rong and Guo Jing come from, and no one paid him? " Jin Yong laughed: "According to Mr. Ling, genius is also a mess." He can't explain it himself.

In fact, reading novels means reading literariness and ideology. Ordinary people like me can just watch interesting plots. There is no need to investigate the details too seriously ~ ~ ~

3. Common sense mistakes in Gu Long's martial arts.

After Jin Yong, I studied Gu Long again.

Because everyone compares Gu Long with Jin Yong, everyone thinks that only one Gu Long is qualified to be with Jin Yong. The first thing I saw was the Chu Liuxiang series.

At first glance, I felt strongly the difference between Gu Long and Jin Yong. From the formal point of view, Gu Long's later works can also be said to represent Gu Long's highest writing level, all of which are "pieced together" by short sentences.

In the process of plot development, some cautionary words are often interspersed. Most of these short sentences are about the relationship between men and women, involving * * * and love.

From the perspective of men, we can understand what love is and what kind of animals women are. After reading these boring sentences, I don't want to read his works anymore.

Occasionally, I looked through his early and middle works, but I thought these works were worth reading, so I went to see his Wulin Scholars, Full Moon Machete and so on. If Jin Yong's works are Chinese paintings, then Gu Long's works are cartoons.

I don't like Gu Long because of my personal reading habits. I don't want to denigrate Gu Long at all. Compared with those writers who imitated Jin Yong's style of writing and those who later imitated him, he has his own unique brilliance.

Someone commented on Gu Long: "Gu Long pursues Europeanization of the language of martial arts novels. He is good at writing short sentences and line by line. There are many epigrams in the dialogue, which explain the ins and outs of things in multiple paragraphs and levels. He tries to write beautiful sentences, which are very interesting and philosophical, giving people a new pattern. Of course, Gu Long's innovation in language cannot be said to be absolutely successful, but after all, Gu Long's new style has broken through the original style of martial arts novels and formed a new language art style of his own. "

This evaluation is very pertinent. His martial arts style, which ignores moves and only talks about artistic conception, strongly reminds me of Japanese action cartoons, such as slam dunks, rogue swords and so on.

Let readers fully feel the senses brought by fighting. People like Chu Liuxiang and Master swordsman are handsome, benevolent, superb in martial arts, with many friends and beautiful women based on a good-looking face.

Their hearts are Japanese, and so are their martial arts. The combination of China and Japan has created these excellent martial arts images. I don't like Gu Long mainly because of his writing style and all-round characterization.

He doesn't have the depth of Jin Yong's research on China culture, and he doesn't have Jin Yong's elegance, which is secondary; The protagonist in the work has many innate elements, and the efforts made the day after tomorrow can't seem to reflect his later success. Chu Liuxiang, for example, is a man of birth and has no past at all.

During his journey, there was no shortage of BMW, cars, beautiful women and good wine, so no one wanted to wander the rivers and lakes, but no one believed it was true. It is human nature to make mistakes once or twice occasionally, which shows Xiang Shuai's love for beautiful women.

Li Xunhuan is better, at least there is a little bit of the past, a little bit of glorious past, exploring flowers and being an official, because I like being a soldier. In a word, I think the characters in Gu Long's works are all stars on the stage. No matter what you do or how you do it, your gestures are bejeweled and impersonal.

Gu Long and his works are more like the products of entertainment society. Maybe it is.

Please list the mistakes in Jin Yong's martial arts novels.

There are too many mistakes! ! ~ ~ ~ I read an article about the mistakes in his novels before. I still remember a paragraph in these articles describing Huang Rong cooking tomatoes for Hong Qigong, but tomatoes are "love apples". For a long time, people were afraid to eat them. China should have been introduced from the outside in the Ming Dynasty. It is against meteorological common sense to describe that the mountain has been closed for more than half a year by heavy snow. What I don't understand most is that people in the Wulin don't work, they walk the rivers and lakes, and they have no salary. Where did the money come from? A while ago, I watched February River on Shenzhen Satellite TV mention this problem and said, "Teacher Jin is really a genius. Where did the money for sightseeing in Huang Rong and Guo Jing come from, and no one paid him? " Jin Yong answered with a smile. "According to Mr. Ling, genius is a mess." He can't explain it himself. In fact, reading novels is just about reading literary thoughts. Ordinary people like me can watch interesting plots. There is no need to pursue details too much.

5. What are the historical mistakes in Jin Yong's novels?

Seven Unknown Historical Errors in Jin Yong's Novel Eight Dragons

Seven historical fallacies in Tian Ba Long Bu: The Age of Akuta?

In "Eight Dragons", Xiao Feng searched for ginseng in the Jurchen Department and became sworn brothers with Akuta! Then, because of the conflict between Jurchen and Qidan people, Yelu Hongji, a Taoist priest in Liao Dynasty, was strengthened and helped Yelu Hongji put down the Yelu Hongji rebellion! Seven Historical Fallacies of Ba Long Department Look at the time and suddenly find that this is a serious BUG. Akuta Wanyan (1068 August1-1123 September 19)

In a.d. 1063, Liao rebelled. At this time, Jurchen Akuta was not born until 1068. Feng Xiao and a ghost who was not born for 5-6 years became sworn brothers.

Mistake 2: Did Liao "mow the grass valley" at the Song-Liao border? This is a typical lie of Black Song and Black Liao! As early as the Yeludeguang era of Emperor Taizong of Liao Dynasty, it was precisely because of the "mowing valley" in the Central Plains after the demise of the Jin Dynasty that the people of the Central Plains rebelled and led to an embarrassing return to Liao. After the revival of Liao, the "mowing valley" has long been abandoned. After Song and Liao signed an agreement in 1005, it was clearly stipulated that "Baigou River is the national border, and both sides withdrew their troops. (Liao returned to Song Suicheng and Ying and Mo Zhou. After that, if fugitives cross the border, they must not stop avoiding each other. " After 1005, the Liao army never invaded the land of the Song Dynasty again until it perished! Mistake 3: Does Yeluhongji want to send troops to invade the Song Dynasty? This is another complete lie. In Liao history, there were two emperors who worshipped Song most, one was Emperor Sheng Zong of Liao and the other was Yelu Hongji of Liao Daoism. When Song's envoy sent Liao a funeral report after his death, Yeluhongji cried and shook the hand of Song's envoy and said, "I haven't known a soldier for 42 years!" Even the most famous one said Lu Ye Hongji's sentence: "May I be born in the Song Dynasty in the next life!" In that case. It is impossible for Yeluhongji to lead troops to attack the Song Dynasty on a large scale.

Mistake 4: The main force of Liao army invaded south, taking Yanmenguan as the main attack direction? God, old man Kim has no military knowledge at all. During the Song and Liao Dynasties, the main attack direction of the Liao army was generally Hebei Road, that is, the North China Plain. Don't go to the west of Taihang Mountain, choose the main battlefield to the east of Taihang Mountain, because the terrain to the east of Taihang Mountain is plain, which is beneficial to the advantage of Liao cavalry and unfavorable to the infantry in the Northern Song Dynasty. It is the stupidest thing to choose Yanmenguan as the main direction of cavalry, that is, Hedong Road west of Taihang Mountain. In the 25-year-long Song-Liao War, except in 980 AD, the Liao army fought in Yanmenguan in retaliation for the attack of the Northern Song Dynasty and suffered losses. No major war chose Yanmenguan as the main battlefield, and even never went to Yanmenguan! Mistake 5: Is Tubo that awesome?

In the Song Dynasty, the Tubo people once had a cow. It was in the era of the true Sect, and the northwest Tubo provoked the Song Dynasty. As a result, Cao Wei, a famous soldier in Song Jun, taught a hard lesson in Sandu Valley. The Tubo people who fought were afraid of the Song Dynasty. In the First World War in Sandu Valley, Song Jun slaughtered tens of thousands of Tubo people and seized more than 30,000 cattle and sheep at the expense of 67 people killed. From then on, the Tubo people were terrified of the Song Dynasty. During the Song Dynasty, the relationship between the Song Dynasty and Dali was good. Dali belongs to the younger brother and vassal of Song Dynasty. Only after the Tubo people were severely beaten by the Song Dynasty did they dare to threaten Dali with force. This is a ridiculous joke. Tubo in the Qing Dynasty, bordering the Song Dynasty, carefully obeyed the Song Dynasty, but later the Song Dynasty occupied more than 2,000 miles of Tubo land by force. Do the Tubo in Song Dynasty dare to be naughty to Song Dynasty? One-tenth of the imperial army in the Song Dynasty can beat the Tubo people back to graze the sheep!

Mistake 6: Can Shaolin's seventy-two stunts improve the fighting capacity of the Liao army? Put the northern song dynasty in disaster? This is the most ridiculous.

Seventy-two Shaolin monks are awesome. I didn't see them kill people with seventy-two stunts. It's really powerful Shaolin directly taught Song Jun the seventy-two stunts, and then wrote a fake one for the Liao warriors, so don't be afraid of anything. Is that Shaolin abbot busy taking so many people to Yanmenguan for adventure? The strength of Liao army lies in cavalry and hundreds of thousands of cavalry. Without these hundreds of thousands of cavalry, you can let the Liao army only use infantry instead of cavalry to fight against Song Jun. Liao army has no * * *, can it persist for 10 years? It is because of the hundreds of thousands of cavalry, Song Liao was bound hands and feet. Without these hundreds of thousands of cavalry, which Liao army is Song Jun's opponent?

Mistake 7: In the war between Song Dynasty and Liao State, the First World War was defeated and the First Division was lost. Song Dynasty fought Liao for 25 years. Where was it ceded? As for the teacher's loss? There were no casualties in Liao army? In the 25-year-long Song-Liao War, only the number of casualties was almost the same as that of Song-Liao. Song Jun killed more than 200,000 enemies. At the time of the alliance, it was clearly stated that "not an inch of land will be given!"