Jiang Mengjie is very beautiful. Why do some viewers not like her character Lin Daiyu but prefer the old version of Lin Daiyu?

"Dream of Red Mansions" has been remade a lot. Why was Jiang Mengjie's version of Lin Daiyu so criticized? Let’s take a look at the image below first.

This is Jiang Mengjie who looks fresh and refined in person, and should be loved by everyone, but the costumes of the entire crew at the time have been criticized, especially the strange "coin coin head".

Looking at the old version of Lin Daiyu (the 1987 version mentioned here is not the first version, but it is the most classic one), it seems that Jiang Mengjie is more attractive to the current audience, which makes me even more puzzled. .

In fact, compared with the old version of Lin Daiyu (played by Chen Xiaoxu) and Jiang Mengjie’s version, Jiang Mengjie’s difference is in her feeling and she has not integrated into the character. First of all, let’s talk about Lin Daiyu played by Chen Xiaoxu. Both appearance and emotion are integrated into the character. Chen Xiaoxu is Lin Daiyu, and Lin Daiyu is Chen Xiaoxu.

It's like stepping out of the book "A Dream of Red Mansions" by Cao Xueqin.

What about Jiang Mengjie’s version? Let’s talk about appearance first. It is written in the book like this: Two eyebrows that look like a frown but not a frown, and a pair of eyes that look like happiness but not joy. The state of mind gives rise to the sorrow of two dimples, and the disease of coquettishness attacks the whole body. Tears a little, panting slightly. Quietness is like a beautiful flower shining on the water, action is like a weak willow supporting the wind. The heart is one more orifice than the stems, and the disease is like Xizi, which is three points better. Jiang Mengjie is very in line with public aesthetics, but she is not suitable to play Lin Daiyu. There is no sense of delicateness and morbidity in her movements.

Secondly, Zhang Ziyi said in "The Birth of an Actor": Real acting skills are to integrate yourself into the role. The role is yourself, and you are the role. And what about Jiang Mengjie? Many of his habits are random and his actions are not sophisticated at all.

How could Lin Daiyu be the real Lin Daiyu without incorporating emotions? In short, Jiang Mengjie is not suitable for the role of Lin Daiyu. This is a major mistake by the director in casting.

(The "Whale Movie" editor's tribe, Sun City, answers questions. Comments are welcome! Leave messages welcome!)

This is Chen Xiaoxu's version of Lin Daiyu's look, an almost perfect classical lady painting.

The 87 version of Lin Daiyu’s image was carefully created by the 87 version’s director, costumer, makeup artist, lighting and photography artist.

Lin Daiyu in the 1987 TV series is delicate and beautiful. However, Chen Xiaoxu's Lin Daiyu is also a unique Lin Daiyu with special charm.

Chen Xiaoxu's Lin Daiyu, her special temperament comes from the "ten years" in which she grew up.

You have to admit that Chen Xiaoxu’s Lin Daiyu has the same spiritual temperament as her contemporary role model “Huang Shuai” when she was growing up.

This is the spirit of the times and an objective existence~ The mark of the times.

After the "ten years" passed, the 1980s ushered in the "Age of Poetry". Chen Xiaoxu's "I am a Catkin" was a literary and artistic young man in that poetic era. It is not surprising to write. However, in today's "poetry-free" era, it is indeed strange.

Chen Xiaoxu's Lin Daiyu reveals the "classmate Huang Shuai" and "Fang Haizhen" who grew up in "ten years". The same spiritual temperament as "comrades".

Jiang Mengjie's generation is a delicate and lovely generation.

A girl who is as delicate and lovely as a flower, did not have "ten years" of material deprivation in her growth, and also There is no fierce fighting spirit in "Ten Years". Jiang Mengjie's Lin Daiyu is the same, she is a delicate and reserved girl.

I say that these two beautiful girls are both Lin Daiyu.

It can be believed.

It can also be said that the difference between the two Daiyu is mainly in the shooting period and style.

However, the difference between the two Daiyu lies in their spiritual temperament. .

Jiang Mengjie’s 10th version of Daiyu is a pure, natural, gentle and elegant girl Lin Daiyu.

Chen Xiaoxu’s 87th version of Daiyu is an ancient, strange and charming beauty. Nie Xiaoqian".

Many fans have learned about Lin Daiyu's family background. Her father, Lin Ruhai, was a former convict and a former concubine. It is considered high, but it can go directly to Tianting. Anyone who is not the emperor's confidant cannot be appointed, and he cannot be allowed to serve again unless he is honest and upright. According to the information, it is not too accurate, so don’t worry too much about it. In short, he is an official with real power and empty duties). Lin Ruhai’s ancestors were marquises for three generations, and Ruhai’s father, with the grace of God, succeeded him for another generation. In other words, the marquis in his family lasted for four generations, ending with Lin Ruhai. If it were an ordinary person, it would gradually become a family of farming and studying, silent in the countryside. But Lin Ruhai is very capable, and he got a real job by himself. , it is still such an important position, if there is no successor, and he died too early, the glory of the Lin family can last for another generation or two. Although it cannot be compared with the aristocratic family, it is not the ordinary family of officials.

The original text of Dream of Red Mansions "Although it is a home of bells and dishes, it is also a home of scholars and officials."

Lin Daiyu's father was so outstanding, and Lin Daiyu's mother was raised in a noble family. Although she died at the beginning of the chapter, just like that, when Lin Daiyu paid a visit to Mrs. Wang, Mrs. Wang later even vomited sour water to Xue Baochai, "Now we The girl at home is better than the girl, but the one back then was really one step ahead.” (I forgot the original words, but that’s what it meant anyway.) Mrs. Jia often said, among my children, the one who hurts the most is She is gone. Now that she is gone, it is like she has taken out my heart. I believe this. Her love for Jia Min directly extends to Daiyu. Sometimes, even Baoyu has to give in. . Jia Min married into the Lin family when the Jia family was at its most glorious. Although the two families were in an alliance, they were still in harmony. This was directly reflected in the fact that after Jia Min's death, Lin Ruhai directly entrusted Gu Rong Guofu to focus on her career. You must know that in ancient times, middle-aged uncles like Lin Ruhai had no worries about marrying a wife. He did not marry again.

Growing up in such a family atmosphere, Lin Daiyu was taught by Tanhua’s father even when she first started school, and she was taught by Mr. Jinshi when she entered school. Her talent is immeasurable. After she went to Rongguofu at the age of seven, she almost never learned knowledge systematically again. She learned everything by herself. In this way, she often shined in poetry gatherings. You know how smart and talented she is. . And because of her generous family and good upbringing, she is truly impeccable. She will be happy with anything that suits her, even if it is a small gadget. If she does not like it, she will dismiss it even if it is extremely valuable. Xue Baochai could tell the usefulness and value of those things at once, and Lin Daiyu only had to consider whether she liked them or not. This was very similar to Jia Baoyu.

Lin Daiyu is not only good at studying and talented, but also has her own mood in life. There is a paragraph of description that is particularly good, but I forgot it. Just remember that when this description came out, what I saw in front of my eyes was In a quiet, small and exquisite bamboo house, she lit a stick of incense, opened a window and covered it with a layer of gauze, letting the wind blow gently. She was reclining and reading before it collapsed. In short, Lin Daiyu was a poet. , is an innocent poet, and a very emotional poet, her whole person is poetic.

The appearance of Lin Daiyu in the old version is really not stunning, but her makeup is particularly suitable, and her temperament is particularly poetic. She can see the essence of Daiyu in the book through the book, and then slowly integrate it with herself , and the actor who plays Daiyu in the old version is a real reader. She has the habit of reading, the enthusiasm for writing poems, and plans for herself. She is a person who is soft on the outside and strong on the inside. This is particularly similar to Daiyu. They both He is the kind of person who has persistence in his heart and is willing to do things that make others look like a joke for his persistence. This is also the reason why audiences still only recognize the old version of Daiyu, because they have a common ground and because they are the same person in certain matters.

To be honest, I haven’t watched a few episodes of the new version of Daiyu. The old version of Daiyu looks very much like what I imagined. When I first entered the Rongguo Mansion, I refused to make any mistakes. Careful and calm, how can the new version of Daiyu, who looked around as soon as she entered the Rongguo Mansion, be comparable? This may be because the acting or the character itself does not have something that fits Daiyu's temperament in the book. It really has nothing to do with appearance.

Among China's four major masterpieces, "A Dream of Red Mansions" is the first. The filming of the 1987 version of "A Dream of Red Mansions" has created a record. Lin Daiyu, played by Chen Xiaoxu, is a classic among classics. No matter the style, makeup, or clothing, it is unparalleled and reaches the limit. The handling of the characters is even more impeccable, unmatched by anyone. The other characters in the play are all excellent and have created history.

Such a successful 1987 version of "Dream of Red Mansions" shows that the creative team's high level, professionalism, hard work, respect for the original work, and insistence on the excellence of the work are such a success. Moreover, the actor selected can almost become one with the protagonist in the book. However, Chen Xiaoxu really seems to live and die for the "Dream of Red Mansions".

Jiang Mengjie’s new version of Lin Daiyu’s “Dream of Red Mansions” was self-defeating because she was not so rigorous in other aspects such as makeup and made new cuts. Beauty is not exactly proportional to the role, it is the suitability for the role that is most important. So for so many years, most viewers still like Lin Daiyu in the 1987 version of Chen Xiaoxu's "Dream of Red Mansions" including all other characters and plots. There is no comparison!

Because classics cannot be surpassed

Lin Daiyu’s character in Dream of Red Mansions is poignant, sensitive and kind. Her situation of being dependent on others makes her always cautious in dealing with others, with a mentality of "fear of being looked down upon"; on the other hand, the small-mindedness of a girl with a bright heart and wisdom can add some "wisdom and cuteness" to her. This makes the character of Lin Daiyu more vivid, flesh-and-blood, and touching. This is the brilliance of the author. In most literary works, the authors often praise the positive characters too much and make the protagonist almost deified. This leads to the creation of characters that is divorced from reality. Life has become boring and boring.

You can tell where the difference is by just looking at the comparison picture

Because she has no classical beauty and her appearance is too modern. I guess I didn’t understand the author’s thoughts and personality after reading A Dream of Red Mansions. , talent, destiny, environment, Lin Daiyu is not performed, but cultivated internally, and that kind of temperament comes with her own. At least she doesn't have that kind of talent, which cannot be achieved by internal cultivation. Jiang Mengjie's eyebrows and expression are particularly unlike Lin Daiyu.

, and everyone in the new version of Dream of Red Mansions is acting and does not understand the characters. It can be seen from their every move and expression that all the actors' costumes are indeed not beautiful.

Being beautiful does not mean that you have good acting skills. "Dream of Red Mansions" inherits traditional Chinese culture. You need to have a very high cultural background to understand Lin Daiyu's characterization. Not ordinary people can act well, and Chen Xiaoxu is Born for "Dream of Red Mansions", she is very talented and exudes a cold yet beautiful otherworldliness in her bones. She uses her heart to understand Lin Daiyu's inner world. Chen Xiaoxu can have a spiritual dialogue with Lin Daiyu, so he can perform Lin Daiyu to perfection.

The most important thing is not whether the actors are beautiful or not, but whether the director, the team, and the film can be watched. No matter how beautiful the actors are, no one will like a bad drama! The new Red Mansion doesn't distinguish between master and servant costumes, the ugly makeup of the actor-like copper coin head, ghostly background music, a lot of narration from the novel, and the casting is extremely unsuccessful, so naturally no one likes it!

It’s not that I don’t like her, it’s her acting skills and interpretation of the role.

Sister Lin played by Chen Xiaoxu is indeed very good, no matter what aspect, but Jiang's Sister Lin has an indescribable feeling, with weird hairstyle and strange clothes, no talent or desolation!

How many current celebrities still read the original work? It’s good to be able to read the script and memorize the lines. Some even don’t memorize the lines and the lip syncs are wrong, so all the dubbing is done for you!

Obviously, it is impossible to fully understand the characters and have a sense of involvement, let alone bring the audience into the play! Why? Because she can't act out the inner drama of the family environment in the context of the times!

Either Chen Xiaoxu plays Lin Daiyu well, she is Lin Daiyu! How to compare?