Help, should I choose Tamron 17-35 or Nikon 18-35 for second-hand wide angle? Poor people

This was all chosen five or six years ago, and there are many new lenses.

Tamron 17-35 was difficult to buy a few years ago, and it has become even harder to find after so many years. The 15-30VC has long since replaced it.

The second generation 18-35 is not as good as the second-hand 16-35, it is wider and comes with VR.

In fact, it is what the rich do if you burn these cheap points, because they will all be sold out in the end.