Traditional Culture Encyclopedia - Photography and portraiture - Which is more important, the screenwriter or the director?

Which is more important, the screenwriter or the director?

There are two main creative positions in film and television works that are particularly attractive. One is the screenwriter of the code word, and the other is the director in charge of shooting and production.

The last job of a screenwriter is the script, and the script, the script and the book of a play are naturally the most important. Script is the foundation, the core and the skeleton. On the basis of the script, the director is an artistic treatment of re-creation and re-vitality.

?

The relationship between the screenwriter and the director is that the screenwriter solves the problem of what to shoot and the director solves the problem of how to shoot. Generally speaking, the relationship between the two is: the relationship between the chef and the purchase of ingredients. The screenwriter provides excellent ingredients and the director cooks delicious food. Therefore, the early screenwriter is important and the late director is important.

When we want to compare two important masters with complex relations, many contradictions and close cooperation, how should we start?

1. Who decides who is important, the screenwriter or the director?

In the commercial society, film and television works should be measured by the market, that is, the audience has the final say, so what do you think the audience values most today? The answer is, of course, the influence of images. Which is more important, the screenwriter or the director? This is equivalent to asking the person responsible for designing the image impact. If the screenwriter understands design, I think he will naturally be the director. Since the screenwriter doesn't understand, in today's situation, of course, the director is important.

2. The director doesn't need a screenwriter.

Too many people think that a director must have a good screenwriter, which is absolutely wrong. The real answer is that a director only needs a good script. More precisely, we only need to identify good scripts. The screenwriter is a person or a group of people, but the script may only have tens of thousands of words or a sheet piling. For example, a novel or a set of novels, some directors can already finish the work, and there is no need for a screenwriter.

3. Objective criteria for defining importance

We can directly measure which position is more important in the movie from another angle. Take remuneration as the standard. This is a very realistic calculation. It is too obvious that whoever is important will get more rewards. So we generally think that the director is more important, because he can get a higher salary. Of course, there are exceptions, but the probability is low. In other words: a good director can save a bad script, and no great screenwriter can save a bad director.

4. Film is a comprehensive creation.

Movies are works of art, and all participants have a certain degree of creative space or auxiliary creation. The only problem is attention. Mass actors, carpenters, light workers and even truck workers are also creating their own works or assisting others in their creation, and their performance will also affect the effect of the whole work. However, a phenomenon that cannot be ignored is that the screenwriter decides the lower limit and the director decides the upper limit.

Screenwriters and directors are simply divided into writing and picture creation, but the real film creation project is very complicated, which is divided into the most primitive concept creation, followed by writing creation, graphic creation, and later music creation, color creation, special effects creation and editing creation. A large number of professional creations complement each other and become the final works. These two positions are people, different people have different energy, and even the same person is not necessarily the same in different situations, so we can't simply compare them. Film creation is holistic, the author is the director, and the screenwriter, like photography director, art director and martial arts director, contributes his own specialty to help the director complete the work.

Answer: Wang Zhongwei, you are invited to pay attention to the official account of WeChat to market flights.