How to evaluate the old and new versions of A Dream of Red Mansions?

How to evaluate the old version of A Dream of Red Mansions and the new version of A Dream of Red Mansions can be evaluated from the following aspects:

1. seriousness of shooting

For the old version and the new version, it is obvious that the old version is better from the seriousness of the writers and actors. The old version has the best restoration of the original work, and the actors have a deeper understanding of the script. Although the new version uses the same script, the visual effect and restoration degree are far less than the old version.

2. Understanding of the culture of A Dream of Red Mansions

The interpretation of A Dream of Red Mansions requires the actors to have a thorough understanding of the original work, from the cognition of Jia's lifestyle in A Dream of Red Mansions to the use of costumes in A Dream of Red Mansions, as well as the tone of speech and the feelings of crying, which the new version obviously cannot do.

3. Rigorous dress and actor selection.

For Wang Xifeng's costume in the original, it is not well reflected in the new edition, because the necklace is wearing a red gold plate and a red flower ring. At the same time, Wang Xifeng's phoenix eye is not dignified at all. At the same time, for the aesthetics of the ancients, it is required that the heaven is full and the face is like a lotus. Those with plump faces are the most popular. For example, Xue Baochai's face is like a silver basin, which is what she said. The old version of A Dream of Red Mansions is better in this respect. The old version of A Dream of Red Mansions rarely has a snake face and uniform eyebrows, while the new version of A Dream of Red Mansions is full of uniform oval faces, copper heads and copper eyebrows, which is nothing new. At the same time, the actor's clothes are cold.