The weather in Jingzhou yesterday

There is such a record in Longzhong Dui: if you have advantages, it will be beneficial to cross the border, keep its rock resistance, enter the west and go out to the south, make friends with Sun Quan outside, and repair politics inside; If the world changes, a general will be ordered to lead Jingzhou troops to Wan and Luo, and the general will lead Yizhou people out of Qinchuan. Who dares to meet the general without eating kettle pulp? From this passage we can see the importance of Jingzhou to Liu Bei. However, in 220 AD, Guan Yu lost the battle of Xiangfan, and then gave Wu Dong general Monroe a chance to cross the Yangtze River in foggy days and seize three important counties in Jingzhou. Since then, the Shu-Han regime has turned from prosperity to decline.

As we all know, Zhuge Liang is known in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Ghosts? In this case, why didn't he anticipate it in advance, or why didn't he prepare for Dongwu defense in advance? On the surface, there are roughly two reasons. The first point is that the plot changes a little unprepared. The battle of Xiangfan can be roughly divided into two stages. The first half was a battle between Shu Han and Cao Wei. At that time, Guan Yu drowned the forbidden army with the help of the local flood in Jingzhou, and at the same time captured Guo Wei's general in Forbidden. It can be said that it was an unprecedented victory, but great changes took place in the second half. Can't storm Fancheng? As a result, the battle of Xiangfan showed fatigue and was finally defeated by Cao Wei's army.

In the second half, Guan Yu was defeated by Dongwu, and the general Lv Meng tore up the Covenant and attacked Jingzhou. Guan Yu, who lost his retreat, fled to Maicheng and was captured. Finally, his father and son were killed together in Soochow. It took about two months. According to the information transmission speed of the ancients, when Guan Yu was defeated, Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei, who were far away in Chengdu, were still celebrating? Drive the seventh army? Victory, so it is a bit unrealistic to make a complete response under such a rare situation change.

The second point is that the Shoujiang of Shu and Han suddenly chose to surrender. When Monroe, the general of the State of Wu, attacked Jingzhou, the commander Mi Fang directly chose to surrender unconditionally. If Mi Fang chooses to temporarily resist, it can give Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei a certain reaction time, so that the Shu and Han forces around Jingzhou can quickly gather and Jingzhou will not fall. Even though Wu Dong started a long time ago? Crossing the river in white? However, if the defenders rely on the strategic terrain of Jingzhou, Nanjun and Lingling, Soochow will not be able to chew this hard bone in a short time.

The above two points are superficial reasons, and the deeper reason is that the general of Shu Han is green and yellow. Guan Yu has been stationed in Jingzhou since he was 48 years old. At that time, one person could scare the whole of Wu Dong to the north. However, after 12, Guan Yu was 60 years old. Although dying heroes can drown the seventh army, their deterrent power is not as good as before. If Liu Bei's talents can replace Guan Yu, it will be difficult for Soochow to break through the dangerous terrain of Jingzhou. Therefore, the attack on Jingzhou was a perfect military action made by Soochow, and the progress of the situation exceeded everyone's expectations. Even if Zhuge Liang can really pinch and calculate, it is absolutely impossible to avoid Guan Yu's downfall. Why didn't Zhuge Liang respond in time to Guan Yu's defeat in Jingzhou? What's your different opinion on three reasons? You can leave a message at the bottom of the article if you have your own opinions.