What would happen if Zhuge listened to Wei and left Xiegu?

In the spring of the sixth year of Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Zhuge Liang, Zhao Yun and Deng Zhi were suspected by Gu Yilu. According to Ji Gu, Cao Zhen, the general of Wei, rejected them.

In winter, Liang returned to Guan and surrounded Chen Cang, but Cao Zhen refused and returned.

The reflection of Cao Zhen pacified the people, Yang Tiao and other officials and people protected the city month by month, and really entered the encirclement. The article said: "The general is coming, and I would like to lower my ear early." So I tied myself out. All three counties are flat.

Zhao Yunchuan of the Three Kingdoms has been stationed in Hanzhong with Zhuge Liang for five years. Next year, the army, lift up their voice by Xiegu Road, Cao Zhen sent all when it. Bright clouds and Deng Zhi refused and attacked Qishan again. Yun and Zhi Dou were weaker than the enemy and defeated by. But they gathered all the people to persevere and didn't suffer a big defeat. Retired from the army and demoted to general of the town army.

In the Spring and Autumn Period of Han, Jin and Qing Dynasties, it was still those who advised Liang to send troops. Liang said, "There are more soldiers in Qishan than thieves. The thief cannot be broken, and the disease is not in the serenade, but in the ear.

Before Zhuge Liang and Brother Jin wrote, they retired and burned Tinglu Road north of Chibi, with a valley of more than a hundred miles. Its pavilion beam is inserted into the hillside, and its pillars are in the water. The water is so big and urgent today that it is impossible to install the column. This is extremely poor but not strong. There is another cloud: when the flood broke out, Chibi was known to be bad by Nanqiao Pavilion. At that time, he and Deng Dou were guarding Chibi and Chibi Pass, but Yanbian and he had only heard of each other.

In the five years after the biography of Wei Yan in the Three Kingdoms, Zhuge Liang was stationed in Hanzhong, with Yan as the commander-in-chief. He led the Prime Minister Sima and Liangzhou to enter Qiang for eight years, and Wei, Fei Yao and Yongzhou made a general after Guo Huai, fought in Yangxi and extended the Huaihe River, moved the former army zones to levy generals in the west, and took a holiday to seal the southern marquis.

Every delay will indicate that we need to recruit 10,000 soldiers, and we will meet a bright road in Tongguan, such as the story of Han Xin, but the light is not allowed. Procrastination is often called brightness, timidity, sighing and hating yourself are endless.

Let Wei Yan out of the inclined valley, certainly better than Zhao Yuntong, whose military strength is really low. When Zhuge Liang summed up the mistakes of the first Northern Expedition, he said that the main reason for Zhao Jiyun's defeat was underestimating his enemy's carelessness, and some historical materials also mentioned that Zhao Yunbing was outnumbered, so the loss of Zhao Yunbing's unified troops had its reasonable premise. Or historical data, by analyzing the distance and time from Meixian to Anding Yueshi City during the first Northern Expedition, figured out that it was not Cao Zhen himself who actually defeated Zhao Yun, but the hidden situation of his left-behind troops in Meixian, which enabled Zhao Yun to retreat calmly. Even so, in order to prevent the pursuit, Zhao Yun actually set fire to the plank road on Chibi, which was really weak to the extreme.

In contrast, Wei Yan's ability to unify troops has to crush several streets in Zhaoyun, Hanzhong's defensive strategy has been effective, Tongguan's bold idea of joining forces in different ways, and Nan 'an Yangxi's solid record of breaking Guo Huai and Yao Fei. It can be said that Wei Yan is the number one general in the Shu army except Zhuge Liang.

Zhuge Liang's first Northern Expedition, if Zhao Yun was not sent out of the inclined valley, he sent Wei Yanling suspected soldiers. Yeh really wanted to get away and go to Longxi. It is estimated that after the withdrawal of the Shu army, the suspected soldiers who did not play a role in Zhao Yun's troops are likely to be infinitely magnified by Wei Yan, and perhaps Meixian can also become a tragic secondary battlefield like a street pavilion. Then after Zhuge Liang left Qishan, there would be no Cao Zhen in Wei Jun in Longxi.

Moreover, Zhuge Liang's second northern expedition to attack Chencang would not have caused inconvenience in transporting rations because of the destruction of the plank road, and tens of thousands of Shu soldiers were forced to retreat because of lack of food.

This shows that Zhuge Liang's first Northern Expedition really misused these two pieces of waste materials of Ma Su Zhaoyun in employing people.