If Guan Yu and Zhao Yun were duel, who would win? What's the basis?

If Guan Yu and Zhao Yun were duel, who would win? What's the basis?

My personal opinion is that if it is purely about force, Zhao Yun will win.

Because "The Romance of the Three Kingdoms" written by Chen Shou is as precious as gold and has too little space to talk about the military force of generals, discussion of the topic of military force must also refer to "The Romance of the Three Kingdoms" written by Luo Guanzhong. Although this seems a bit imprecise, there are too few official historical details and there is not much room for discussion on this topic.

1. Reputation in the industry

We can recall the attitude of the military generals towards the two men in the Three Kingdoms military generals community. You will find that many enemy generals are unconvinced when facing Guan Yu and want to provoke him. For example, famous generals such as Xu Chu, Xu Huang, Pang De, and Huang Zhong have all threatened to take down Guan Yu, and the fact is that they did so on a single basis. It is true that Guan Yu cannot defeat them.

However, there are still some unknown generals who dare to talk nonsense about Guan Yu, such as Cai Yang and Qin Qi, which is a bit excessive. This also shows in disguise that Guan Yu's singles ability in the military general world is not unattainable.

However, many generals often remain silent when facing Zhao Yun, and they bite the bullet as a last resort. Why? It's easy to understand. Zhao Yun has had a distinguished record since he came out of the mountain, and his ability in single combat is obvious. The most convincing thing is that Zhao Yun has been beaten by groups many times, but he can remain undefeated, which is rare. Therefore, others think that Zhao Yun's kung fu is too stable, and he has no flaws in both offense and defense. It is difficult to defeat him. This can be seen from the fact that Guan Yu repeatedly hit arrows and Zhao Yun could always block them. Zhao Yun's skills were perfect, but Guan Yu had his flaws.

2. Weapons and routines

Guan Yu uses a sword and Zhao Yun uses a gun. These two weapons naturally have different characteristics and routines.

Judging from historical results, Guan Yu usually kills his opponents with heavy cuts in the first three rounds. Including warming wine and killing Hua Xiong, killing Yanliang, killing Wen Chou, etc., they are all fast and fierce. Once the opponent blocked Er Ye's first few blows, Er Ye's victory rate plummeted. This is actually in line with the routine of using a broadsword. A broadsword often relies on the speed of a horse to form a powerful cutting force. Can you suddenly imagine that Yan Liang died unjustly? Once entering the fighting round, the horse speed is lost and the power is suddenly reduced.

Furthermore, the sword consumes much energy and cannot be fought for a long time, so Guan Yu tied with Xiahou Dun, tied with Xu Huang, tied with Huang Zhong, and tied with Pang De in the front. Why? Because of the lack of stamina, if you are blocked by your opponent in front, you will be in trouble later.

Looking back at Zhao Yun's record, he was undefeated at a young age when he was head-on and Wen Chou was undefeated at fifty or sixty. After that, no one could stop him: Ju Yi was stabbed to death with one spear, Gao Lan was overthrown with one spear, Xu Chu was tied with thirty, Zhang He was defeated with thirty, Li Dian was defeated with more than ten, etc. It can be called a duel between Shu and Han. king. We can find through observation that Zhao Yun's marksmanship is both sharp and durable. In his early years, he was able to compete with the first-class famous military generals, and his marksmanship was solid and sharp, and he became more brave as he fought.

Conclusion

To sum up, I personally think that if Guan Yu and Zhao Yun were dueling, Zhao Yun would be better.