The man's hotel fell down the stairs and died. My friend said that I didn't know that the so-called monitoring of the hotel was not good.

It was a happy thing for friends to get together for dinner and drinking, but when it comes to this crop, Mr. Liu of Jinan is never happy. His father-in-law ate in a restaurant the other day and drank a little too much. After dinner, he accidentally fell down the stairs. As a result, he never woke up.

Friends don't know, the monitoring is broken.

Mr. Liu said that on the evening of March 1 1, his father-in-law and some friends had dinner at Huayin restaurant. 10, his mother-in-law called him and said that his father-in-law was in the hospital for emergency treatment. When they arrived at the hospital, his father-in-law was dying. What makes Mr. Liu even more angry is that there were several friends who were drinking with his father at that time, but when Mr. Liu asked about the situation at that time, their answers were quite consistent: I don't know.

Mr. Liu then contacted Huayin Hotel where the incident occurred, and the proprietress of the hotel gave a reply. Mr. Liu's father did fall down at that time. However, when Mr. Liu asked to see the surveillance video of the hotel at the time of the incident, he was told that the surveillance camera was broken that day.

Mr. Liu doesn't believe in the problems in monitoring. He thinks the surveillance video was deleted by the boss himself. He suspected that his father-in-law didn't just fall down at that time, so he wanted to restore the truth at that time through the monitoring screen. After the coordination of the police, the hotel owner agreed to hand over the storage hard disk of the surveillance video. Yesterday afternoon, Mr. Liu submitted the hard disk to the technical department for data recovery.

Expert analysis

If the deceased under surveillance really falls down on the hotel stairs and dies, who will bear the responsibility? The reporter then called Shandong Xinliang Law Firm for consultation. Lawyer Chen told reporters that hotels should fulfill their security obligations, such as installing guardrails and signs beside stairs, and video surveillance is sufficient evidence to show whether hotels have fulfilled their security obligations. In addition, for the accidental death caused by drinking, especially when going down the stairs, as other people who drink together, if they don't give help or care, they will bear certain responsibilities.

Related case

Mr. Gao, a citizen of Shanghai, unfortunately fell down the hotel stairs and died after a party with friends. After a dinner, it turned out to be farewell. Mr. Gao's family angrily took the hotel to court and claimed more than 730,000 yuan. Shanghai No.1 Intermediate People's Court disclosed today that a final judgment has been made on this case recently, and the hotel has to bear 30% of the liability for compensation because there are no handrails on the stairs.

After the trial, the First Intermediate People's Court held that the medical certificate of death was an important evidence to judge Mr. Gao's death. After on-the-spot investigation by the court, the steepness of the hotel stairs is still within a reasonable range, the steps have obvious friction, and the corridor lights are not dim. Mr. Gao's family also failed to prove that the stairs were greasy and slippery. However, it is an indisputable fact that there are no continuous handrails on the stairs involved. Compared with other public places, it is more necessary to set up handrails in view of the fact that customers often drink too much or even get drunk. Therefore, there is a defect in the setting of stairs, which has a certain causal relationship with Mr. Gao's death. In this regard, the court held that the hotel should bear 30% of the compensation liability for the reasonable losses of Mr. Gao's family, that is, compensation of more than 220,000 yuan.