Comment template of graduation thesis reviewers

Whether the thesis defense argument is good or not is an important part of whether the defense can be successfully passed and whether it can be successfully graduated; The following is a template with reviewers' comments on graduation thesis. Please refer to.

Comment template of graduation thesis reviewers

1, the topic is novel, closely combined with clinical practice, and the design is reasonable, which belongs to the research hotspot of this discipline, and the research work has certain theoretical significance and practical value. The content of the paper is basically consistent with the topic, with complete structure, standardized format, clear hierarchy, clear organization, fluent language and rich content. The collected literature is rich and detailed, basically covering the main literature related to this discipline, which has a certain inductive effect on the development trend of this discipline. Sufficient data, rigorous discussion process, clear thinking, comprehensive application of learned knowledge to solve problems, proper selection of analysis methods, and credible results. The paper is carefully written, the reasoning is logical, and the conclusions and suggestions are of practical significance. It is a master's thesis with high academic value.

2. From the defense, it can be seen that this student has a solid professional foundation, is well prepared, is very familiar with the content of the paper, can concisely and clearly state the design ideas and processes, systematically display smoothly, answer questions well-founded, have clear basic concepts, and have some innovations in the paper. I hope to continue to improve some words and symbols in the paper and strive for standardized use.

3._ _ _ An Empirical Study on the Influence of Online Shopping Website Experience on Consumers' Online Purchase Intention, based on the research of relevant literature and the dynamic analysis of current events, studies the elements of website experience and the influence of website experience on consumers' online purchase intention, and its topic selection has certain theoretical value and practical significance.

4. The documents cited in this paper are representative and scientific, and the relevant Chinese and foreign documents are comprehensively analyzed and summarized, and the research background, research status and development prospect of _ _ _ _ are mastered, and the literature review is rich and standardized.

In the ten-minute presentation, the student introduced the main points, content and structure of the paper, as well as the writing process of the paper. The organization is clear, the language is correct, and the teacher's questions are basically answered correctly, which reflects a certain professional quality. However, there are some minor problems in the design process and the flow chart is not perfect. I hope to correct it in time.

6._ _ _ Student Dissertation "Analysis and Research on Data Model of Undergraduate Specialty Setting Prediction System Based on Data Mining" is selected from the undergraduate specialty setting prediction system project entrusted by the Ministry of Education of Sun Yat-sen University. The research results of this paper have certain guiding significance for the construction of undergraduate specialty setting prediction system in colleges and universities.

7. In the five-minute presentation, the student introduced the main content and structure of the paper, as well as the research conducted for this purpose, which showed that he had a certain understanding of the research issues. The video design is beautiful, but it doesn't meet the professional requirements. It will be better to design the implementation process from the perspective of computer science.

8. With the help of statistical analysis software, the influencing factors are analyzed. The paper is rich in content, clear in organization, complete in structure, detailed in data collection, accurate in data, clear and powerful in argument, fully reliable in argument and reliable in conclusion.

9. This student has good professional quality, fluent answers, high correct rate, good understanding of the problems encountered in the implementation process and proper timing. It will be better if it can be implemented in a relatively new operating environment.

10, the paper is clearly stated, come straight to the point, and get to the point directly. I can answer the teacher's questions fluently and think clearly, but I can't correctly explain some codes in the paper and there are a few language errors. I hope there will be more innovations in future research.

1 1. Combining with mathematical knowledge, using computer technology to deal with geological problems, the paper has a thorough grasp of methods and principles, and the paper is innovative. The results of fast Fourier transform and wavelet transform are analyzed in place, and the processing effect is good, and the computer basic literacy is good. The answers to the main questions in the defense are accurate and thorough. It would be better if there is a contrast between the converted indicators in this paper.

12. The student explained the main contents of the paper fluently and clearly within the specified time, and was able to answer the questions related to the paper properly, with a modest attitude and a solid computer foundation. It is suggested to use appropriate words to express the image opening function and standardize the paper format.

13, the topic of this paper is reasonable, which provides theoretical support for _ _, and the research is of great significance.

14. The student fluently stated the purpose, theoretical and practical significance of writing this paper. The design process of antique websites is standardized, but there is little connection between entities and concepts. The whole design should meet the requirements of the computer as much as possible.

15. This paper reflects the author's solid theoretical foundation, systematic professional knowledge and good scientific research ability in this subject. It meets the requirements of master's degree thesis, and it is suggested to arrange a defense.

16. The student expressed clearly and answered questions fluently. Although the paper has a good idea and certain research value, the framework and content are huge, which requires strong independent research ability, and the title of the paper and the client login server module need to be slightly modified. The students are well prepared, the link sentences are complete, the thesis is clearly conceived, which embodies a good professional foundation and a good grasp of time. That is, there is demand in the paper but there is a lack of demand analysis, and the answers to some defense questions are not clear, and the graphic representation is not standardized.

17. The writing of the thesis conforms to the standard of postgraduate thesis, and the academic level is good, which reflects the results of two years' study and can enter the defense procedure.

18, fully prepared for defense, able to answer the teacher's questions in detail, able to repeatedly discuss and study the difficulties encountered in the design process to find a better solution, and good professional skills. It would be better if the static web page can be made dynamic by combining professional improvement, but the deficiency is that the description of the table in the database is not quite right, and I hope it can be improved.

19. During the defense, students can skillfully and concisely state the main contents of the paper within the specified time, with clear organization and obvious innovation, quick response when answering questions, accurate expression, skilled system demonstration and high professional quality. After deliberation by the defense Committee, it was unanimously agreed that his grades were excellent.

20. The research results of this paper show that the research on _ _ _ has strong practical value and maneuverability, which fully reflects the author's comprehensive knowledge of _ _ _, and has experience, analysis, thinking and suggestions on _ _ _ _ practice.

2 1. Students use dreamweave and access database technology to design Ganzi tourism website. The design is fresh and beautiful, the main questions are answered accurately, and the basic concepts are clear. I want to correct the database storage problem in the file.

22. The paper has a rigorous structure, distinct levels, progressive analytical structure, strong logic, fluent writing, clear expression and prominent viewpoints. The format of this article conforms to academic norms. It shows that the author has strong independent scientific research ability. The paper shows that the author has mastered the basic theory and analysis method of enterprise management, and the paper has reached the level of master's degree thesis. You are allowed to participate in thesis defense, and it is recommended to award a master's degree.

23. The paper is good at thinking and synthesizing, but it lacks consideration of actual needs and situations, such as users' demand for professional settings and the collectability and availability of data in data mining. It is suggested that a broader perspective should be adopted in related research in the future.

24. The student explained the design details of the database in detail, did in-depth research, independently completed the design of the forum, and had certain scientific research ability, clear thinking in the defense, and concise and smooth answers. After careful discussion, the defense team agreed that the student's performance was good, but asked the student to correct some mistakes in the paper.

25. The student can state the main content of the paper within the specified time, but the answer to questions in the defense is not very smooth, he is not familiar with the details and techniques of design, and the answer to questions is not relevant enough.

26. The format of the paper is correct, the structure is rigorous, the levels are distinct, the writing is standardized, the logic is strict, the language is fluent, and the focus is prominent, which shows that the author has strong independent scientific research ability. The thesis is excellent in general, and I agree to submit a defense, suggesting that I be awarded a master's degree in agriculture.

27. Elaborate the thesis from five parts, with prominent points, fluent and skilled defense, basic knowledge in place and time meeting the requirements. The disadvantage is that there are some conceptual mistakes in the article.

28. It is found that seven aspects of website experience, namely usability experience, usefulness experience, visual experience, price experience, commodity experience, service experience and reputation experience, can well explain the connotation of website experience. Using SOR model, it is found that website experience has a significant positive impact on purchase intention, and emotion and perceived risk are some intermediary variables between website experience and purchase intention. The paper uses normative analysis and empirical analysis to prove its own point of view, and the research method is more scientific. The innovations of this paper are as follows: firstly, a new model of website experience research is constructed; Secondly, using the empirical analysis method systematically, this paper analyzes the factors that affect the online purchase intention from multiple angles. This paper has considerable theoretical depth. The paper has clear viewpoints, clear and powerful arguments, sufficient and reliable arguments, accurate data, detailed information and rich and standardized literature review, among which there are some new views on the influence of website experience on purchase intention. The disadvantage is that the dimension of website experience is not comprehensive enough, especially the technical factors of the website. In the future, we can consider studying the interpretation of website experience by website technical factors such as network speed.

29. This paper mainly studies the data model of undergraduate specialty setting prediction system. Firstly, this paper summarizes the existing data models of specialty setting, and analyzes their shortcomings in functionality, predictability, analysis and mining. Then, combined with the actual demand of undergraduate specialty setting in colleges and universities, data mining technology, data warehouse and OLAP are introduced to construct the data model of undergraduate specialty setting prediction system based on data mining. Generally speaking, the framework of the paper is clear, the logic is rigorous, and the writing reflects my own academic thinking and speculative conclusions, and I have my own unique opinions.

30. The paper is clearly stated and the explanation is simple and clear. However, the deficiency lies in the lack of new ideas and methods, mostly applying other people's research results, and the format of the paper should be standardized.

Selected Review Templates of Graduation Thesis Reviewer

1. Instructor Comments Writing Requirements: Paper Writing: How to choose a topic, finalize several drafts of the outline, and revise the paper several times. Students' performance in the process of thesis writing. Viewpoint and content evaluation: whether the viewpoint is correct and whether the main content of the paper has original or meaningful opinions. Evaluation of paper structure: whether the central idea is prominent, whether the hierarchical structure and argumentation are sufficient. Evaluation of language expression: whether the writing is fluent and the language is standardized. Scoring opinions.

2. Requirements for reviewers to write comments: evaluation of the title of the paper, evaluation of the writing of the paper: viewpoint, content, structure, language, etc. Comment on the shortcomings of the paper.

3. Requirements for the resolution writing of the defense committee: evaluation, topic selection and main contents of the paper. Evaluation of the report: whether the main content, structure and conclusion of the paper can be clearly reported within the specified time. Evaluation of answering questions: the defense Committee raised several questions and summarized the answers to the questions raised.

First, the topic of this paper is reasonable. The regional economic problem is the focus of economic research, and the economic growth in the central region is also the focus of discussion at present. In recent years, many experts at home and abroad have conducted many mature discussions on this issue, and some experts and scholars in Shanxi have also conducted in-depth research on the economic problems in central China, but no special discussion on the comprehensive study of Shanxi's agricultural regional economy and its growth has been found. How to understand the present situation and future trend of regional economic differences in Shanxi agriculture and promote the healthy and sustained growth of agricultural economy is an urgent problem to be solved in economic reality, and it is also the significance of this paper.

Second, the data is accurate and the analysis method is properly selected. The opening report can be based on the actual situation in Shanxi, collect a large number of data and choose more advanced analysis methods (cluster analysis, principal component analysis, B? J prediction, R/S analysis, nonlinear regression), with the help of statistical analysis software to do a lot of simulation experiments, based on the relevant regional economic theory, this paper makes an empirical study on the present situation and influencing factors of agricultural regional economic differences in Xinjiang, the development trend of agricultural regional economic differences and its influence on economic growth, and puts forward corresponding policy suggestions.

Thirdly, combining qualitative analysis with quantitative analysis, the conclusions and suggestions are reasonable. This paper focuses on the elaboration of theoretical basis and qualitative analysis of model analysis results, and makes a trial calculation and rationality analysis of the selected analysis methods in the writing process. The research results of regional differences in agriculture in Xinjiang are consistent with the actual situation and related research results, and the suggestions put forward are more targeted and operable.

This paper is correct in topic selection, reasonable in structure, rich in content, sufficient in data and materials, advanced in analysis method, reasonable in writing progress, and the conclusions and suggestions have regional practical significance. The recommendation is an excellent graduation thesis at the university level.

Comments of reviewers (the value and significance of the selected topic, workload, standardization of writing, existing problems, suggestions on evaluation results, whether it is possible to submit a defense, etc.). )

Land system reform is a hot research field that is widely concerned by academic circles and society at present. What does this student choose? Land expropriation compensation system? Conduct research and choose new topics. This subject has certain difficulty and moderate workload, which meets the professional training objectives.

Based on the problems existing in the current land expropriation compensation system, this paper analyzes the research status in this field in China, comprehensively analyzes the related problems of the land expropriation compensation system, and designs short, medium and long-term solutions to the problems. . .

The paper shows that the student has consulted a large number of documents and materials, and has a certain ability of literature review and data collation. The content of the paper is relatively complete, the hierarchical structure is clear, the main points are prominent and the logic is strong, which shows that the student has a certain ability to work independently. The paper is fluent and achieves the training goal of undergraduates.

In my opinion, the thesis has reached the level of bachelor's degree thesis, and I agree to defend the thesis.

Comments of the defense group (students' knowledge, logical thinking ability, oral expression ability, correctness of answering questions, etc.). )

During the defense, the student introduced the main points and contents of the paper and answered the questions of the defense members. The defense shows that the student has a deep research on the land expropriation compensation system, collated a large number of documents, has a certain ability of literature review, and has innovation in the research of land expropriation compensation. The students' answers to the teacher's questions are basically correct. In addition, there are still some shortcomings in the paper, such as the deep-seated basic theoretical issues involved in land expropriation are not discussed deeply enough.

Based on the opinions of the tutor and reviewers and the performance of the student in the defense process, the defense team unanimously agreed to pass the defense of the student's graduation thesis after careful discussion, and suggested granting a bachelor's degree.

Excellent graduation thesis reviewer comment template

1. This paper studies the official accountability system, which can provide reference for solving the problems existing in the official accountability system in China. In the structure of the full text, the practical significance of the official accountability system is analyzed first, and then the official accountability system in China is analyzed.

2. Take _ _ as the research topic. It can provide reference for solving the _ _ problem. In the structure of the full text, we should first adjust the basic concepts, ask questions, then make in-depth analysis of the problems, and finally put forward effective suggestions for _. The full text reflects the requirements of professional characteristics, some of which are closely related to responsibilities, and there are not many contents that really belong to their own innovation. Generally speaking, it meets the requirements of graduation thesis.

3. The title of the full text is _ _. Pay attention to the problem of _ _, and then put forward effective suggestions for the problem. The structure of the full text meets the requirements, the logical thinking is clear, the arguments are sufficient, the viewpoints are expressed accurately, the language is fluent, and the argumentation method is reasonable. The reference materials are closely combined with the theme.

4. Make an in-depth analysis of the dilemma, and finally put forward effective suggestions to solve the dilemma. The full text reflects the requirements of professional characteristics, meets the training requirements of administrative management specialty, and the references meet the needs of the paper's viewpoints and themes, and the practical demonstration is not enough. But there is not much real innovation. Generally speaking, it meets the requirements of graduation thesis.

5. The paper has clear ideas and fluent sentences. Can be a good investigation of _ _ existing problems. The author has a certain understanding and familiarity with the content of the paper. Clear thinking, clear hierarchy and reasonable logical structure. The viewpoint is expressed accurately. The research principles are appropriate. In the process of demonstration, we can effectively combine professional principles with the topics to be studied. The opinions demonstrated in some places are not very clear, and generally meet the requirements of graduation thesis.

6. This paper studies the official accountability system, which can provide reference for solving the problems existing in the official accountability system in China. In the structure of the full text, firstly, the basic principle of the official accountability system is analyzed, then the problems existing in the official accountability system in China are deeply analyzed, and finally, effective suggestions are put forward for the previous problems. The full text reflects the requirements of professional characteristics, some of which are closely related to responsibilities, and there are not many contents that really belong to their own innovation. Generally speaking, it meets the requirements of graduation thesis.

7. Paper comments? Excellent: the topic of the thesis conforms to the professional training goal and can achieve the comprehensive training goal. The topic is difficult and the workload is heavy. The topic selection has high academic research (reference) value (great practical guiding significance). The student has a strong ability to consult documents and materials, and can comprehensively collect information about the examination system. In the process of writing, I can comprehensively apply the knowledge of the examination system and comprehensively analyze the problems existing in the examination system, and I have a strong ability to comprehensively apply knowledge. The length of the article fully conforms to the requirements of the college, with complete content, scientific hierarchical structure, prominent points, clear logical relationship and certain personal opinions. The topics are completely consistent, the arguments are prominent, and the discussion is closely related to the theme. The language expression is fluent, and the format fully meets the requirements of the specification; Rich references and strong timeliness; There is no plagiarism.

8. The structure of the full text is basically reasonable and scientific, the logical thinking is clear, the viewpoints are expressed accurately, the language is fluent, the argumentation method is reasonable, the references meet the theme requirements, the theme and content meet the professional requirements, and some of them are closely related to this part, but individual quotations are not marked, and there are not many truly innovative contents, and individual concepts are vague, which generally meet the requirements of graduation thesis.

9, learning _ _ topic, fully reflect the characteristics of the times. It can provide reference value for solving administrative problems in China. The full text is reasonable in structure, clear in thinking and obvious in viewpoint. What can be taught well in the process of argumentation is to combine argumentation with case argumentation. The disadvantage is that some arguments are not convincing. Thesis review

10, full text title _ _, novel and practical topic. The full text has scientific and reasonable structure, strong logic and clear thinking, and the references consulted meet the requirements of the paper. The demonstration method is reasonable. The content of the argument is more convincing. The analysis of the problem is more thorough. In the process of demonstration, students can also combine the principles of administrative professional knowledge with social reality. Whether it is from the topic selection or viewpoint demonstration, it meets the requirements of the training objectives of administrative management specialty. But innovation is not enough.

1 1. The topic is in line with the training objectives of the administrative management major, and can better comprehensively apply social theory and professional knowledge. The writing attitude of the thesis is serious and responsible. The content of the paper is sufficient, the relevant reference materials are sufficient, and the hierarchical structure is reasonable. The main points are prominent, the logical points are clear, and the language expression is fluent. But the depth of the argument is not enough.

12, the topic selection is more contemporary and realistic. The structure of the full text is reasonable. The expression of views is basically accurate. The full text closely follows the requirements of the administrative management specialty and fully embodies the characteristics of the administrative management specialty. Check out more related information. But the main deficiency is that there are not many things that belong to their own innovation. Generally speaking, it meets the requirements of graduation thesis.

13, the topic is contemporary and realistic, the structure of the full text is reasonable, the viewpoints are basically accurate, and the ideas are basically clear. The content of the full text is basically written according to the training requirements of the administrative management major, and I have consulted a lot of relevant materials, but it does not fully reflect the characteristics of the administrative management major, and there are not many things that belong to my own innovation. Generally speaking, it meets the requirements of graduation thesis.

14, this paper takes _ _ as the theme, and the topic selection has strong reality and application, which meets the requirements of the training goal of administrative management specialty. The structure of this paper is basically reasonable, and the full text is divided into _ _ _ parts. The first part focuses on this basis. In the process of demonstration, students' reference materials are closely combined with the viewpoints and contents to be demonstrated, and the research methods adopted are mainly theoretical research and case study. Words are basically accurate. However, the main problem is that the arguments are not sufficient and convincing, and individual quotations do not indicate the source.

15. The references in this paper are sufficient and meet the needs of the topic. Taking _ _ as an example, this paper focuses on _ _. The topic of this paper meets the requirements of administrative management, with complete structure, clear thinking, accurate expression of views and standardized format, and can better use administrative professional knowledge to analyze practical administrative problems in reality. But the argument of personal views is not sufficient. Generally speaking, it meets the requirements of graduation thesis.