Zhanjiang man jumped off a building and killed passers-by in the hotel after killing. Can the families of passers-by claim compensation from the hotel?

This case is strange and complicated beyond everyone's imagination.

Time:1October 4th afternoon 165438+ 19 Location: Chikan District, Zhanjiang, Guangdong.

Yang Xiaoming, 55, hacked Miao Xiaoming, 54, to death because of an argument between them. After the murder, Yang jumped from the 43rd floor of Wanda Apartment in the development zone of the city at 0: 00 on the 5th, just hitting 45-year-old passers-by Zhou Xfang and Yang Xming in An, Shaanxi, and died on the spot. Zhou Xfang was taken to the hospital and died after being rescued, so Yang Xming alone caused them to perish together.

In recent years, there have been many suicides by jumping off a building, but not many suicides by jumping off a building to kill passers-by, because it is so coincidental. For example, Zhou Xfang jumped from the 43rd floor, just walking in the falling area of Yang Xming at that time. This joint is too strange, so it is not appropriate to say that killing people can only be an accident. Zhou X was killed innocently. Of course, the Zhou family couldn't let go, but Yang Xming didn't leave a legacy. The Zhou family could not claim compensation from the Yang family, so they thought of the hotel.

Legally speaking, the Zhou family can claim compensation from the hotel, because after all, they jumped from the 43rd floor of the hotel. According to reports, after the murder, Yang Mouming fled the scene and lived in Wanda Apartment knowing that he could not escape the death penalty. Yang Xiaoming wants to die. At first, he smashed the glass and planned to jump from the window. I didn't expect the double glass to be particularly strong and difficult to break open, so he smashed the window stopper, opened the glass window and jumped directly.

According to the hotel staff, they heard the movement in the room rented by Yang Xming and wanted to rush in to stop it, but it was locked and could not be opened. When the door was broken into, Yang Xiaoming had jumped down from the upstairs. The hotel also feels wronged, but the criminals can't escape the responsibility if something happens from the guest room.

In fact, after careful analysis, it is necessary for the hotel to make some compensation. If security window is installed outside the window, Yang Xming can't jump down anyway. If you set up a device to intercept threatening items outside the floor, it can also play a buffering role. Moreover, the location of this floor is too close to expressway, so a person can bump into pedestrians on the road if he jumps from the upstairs. If someone deliberately throws a parabolic object at high altitude, will it also hit innocent people?

From this point of view, the main road adjacent to the hotel is neglected, and it is indeed thoughtless in construction. A strange case happened in my friend's city last year. A man rode a battery car through a tall building and was hit on the shoulder by a pencil falling from the upstairs. It was summer, and his clothes were thin. After being recruited, people fell to the ground. After pulling out the pencil, his shoulder bled. Innocent passers-by called the police because they couldn't see the perpetrators. After careful investigation according to the nearby camera and the direction in which the pencil fell, the police finally locked the source of the pencil. It turned out that two children of a family on 18 floor were fighting and threw the pencil out of the window. Unexpectedly, they bumped into innocent passers-by. No way, the guardian can only compensate the injured. This incident is thought-provoking.